This is a special post for quick takes by Wei Dai. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
AI labs are starting to build AIs with capabilities that are hard for humans to oversee, such as answering questions based on large contexts (1M+ tokens), but they are still not deploying "scalable oversight" techniques such as IDA and Debate. (Gemini 1.5 report says RLHF was used.) Is this more good news or bad news?
Good: Perhaps RLHF is still working well enough, meaning that the resulting AI is following human preferences even out of training distribution. In other words, they probably did RLHF on large contexts in narrow distributions, with human rater who have prior knowledge/familiarity of the whole context, since it would be too expensive to do RLHF with humans reading diverse 1M+ contexts from scratch, but the resulting chatbot is working well even outside the training distribution. (Is it actually working well? Can someone with access to Gemini 1.5 Pro please test this?)
Bad: AI developers haven't taken alignment seriously enough to have invested enough in scalable oversight, and/or those techniques are unworkable or too costly, causing them to be unavailable.
From my experience doing early RLHF work for Gemini, larger models exploit the reward model more. You need to constantly keep collecting more preferences and retraining reward models to make it not exploitable. Otherwise you get nonsensical responses which have exploited the idiosyncracy of your preferences data. There is a reason few labs have done RLHF successfully.
This seems to be evidence that RLHF does not tend to generalize well out-of-distribution, causing me to update the above "good news" interpretation downward somewhat. I'm still very uncertain though. What do others think?
Bad: AI developers haven't taken alignment seriously enough to have invested enough in scalable oversight, and/or those techniques are unworkable or too costly, causing them to be unavailable.
Turns out at least one scalable alignment team has been struggling for resources. From Jan Leike (formerly co-head of Superalignment at OpenAI):
Over the past few months my team has been sailing against the wind. Sometimes we were struggling for compute and it was getting harder and harder to get this crucial research done.
I'm skeptical that increased scale makes hacking the reward model worse. Of course, it could (and likely will/does) make hacking human labelers more of a problem, but this isn't what the comment appears to be saying.
Note that the reward model is of the same scale as the base model, so the relative scale should be the same.
This also contradicts results from an earlier paper by Leo Gao. I think this paper is considerably more reliable than the comment overall, so I'm inclined to believe the paper or think that I'm misunderstanding the comment.
Additionally, from first principles I think that RLHF sample efficiency should just increase with scale (at least with well tuned hyperparameters) and I think I've heard various things that confirm this.