This is a special post for quick takes by oligo. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
If you live in a universe with self-consistent time loops, amor fati is bad and exactly the wrong approach. All the fiction around this, of course, is about the foolishness of trying to avoid one's fate; if you get a true prophecy that you will kill your father and marry your mother, then all your attempts to avoid it will be what brings it about, and indeed in such a universe that is exactly what would happen. However, a disposition to accept whatever fate decrees for you makes many more self-consistent time loops possible. If on the contrary your stance is "if I get a prophecy that something horrible happens I will do everything in my power to avert it," then fewer bad loops would hypothetically complete, and you're less likely to get the bad prophecy (even though, if you do, you'd be just as screwed, and presumably less miserable about it and foolish-looking than if you had just accepted it from the beginning.)
(If you live in a nice normal universe with forward causality this advice may not be very useful, except in the sense that you should also not submit to prophecies, albeit for different reasons.)
You may already know of this, but Gwern circa 2023 makes this argument here:
In stable time-loops, “possibility implies actuality”.
With this in mind, we can ask again: why did this protagonist get trapped in that time-loop, and not, say, his wife? The key, I think, is that the protagonist does not seem upset at the murder or any of the other timecrimes, and he appears to have every intention of covering up the crime to continue his ordinary retired life. A sinister undertone creeps in to his casualness in executing the scenario: he goes along with it too ea... (read more)
You may be interested in Scott Aaronson et al's paper on the subject of computability theory of closed timelike curves
[...]
6Shankar Sivarajan
On the contrary, I would expect the amor fati people to get normal prophecies, like, "you will have a grilled cheese sandwich for breakfast tomorrow," "you will marry Samantha from next door and have three kids together," or "you will get a B+ on the Chemistry quiz next week," while the horrible contrived destinies come to those who would take roads far out of their way to avoid them.