This is a special post for quick takes by jelly. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
I have an intuition that the mud-rock spectrum is a very important concept to pay attention to, and the rationality community leaned too hard on muddiness and muddy rationalist techniques, and that this is underemphasized among rationalists. (for example, metacognitivestrategies, a CFAR situation, the fact that you have to quickly replace some of your assumptions as you become a rationalist, the quick development of rationality and foundational beliefs on LessWrong in general, ...) I personally feel like some of the framing of the concept in the mud-rock post isn't quite right (muddiness/rockiness probably isn't best described as a state of mind), but the conceptual understanding behind it basically is. In a very rough summary, things are "muddier" when they change deeper/more foundational beliefs/assumptions, and things are "rockier" when they harden them instead. I think that paranoia is a good step in the right direction here, and that people should develop more rationality techniques in the general rocky direction. (something something Chesterton's fence?)