The Definition of Good and Evil
Epistemic Status: I feel like I stumbled over this; it has passed a few filters for correctness; I have not rigorously explored it, and I cannot adequately defend it, but I think that is more my own failing than the failure of the idea.
I have heard said that "Good and Evil are Social Constructs", or "Who's really to say?", or "Morality is relative". I do not like those at all, and I think they are completely wrong. Since then, I either found, developed, or came across (I don't remember how I got this) a model of Good and Evil, which has so far seemed accurate in every situation I have applied it to. I don't think I've seen this model written explicitly anywhere, but I have seen people quibble about the meaning of Good & Evil in many places, so whether this turns out to be useful, or laughably naïve, or utterly obvious to everyone but me, I'd rather not keep it to myself anymore.
The purpose of this, I guess, is that when the map has become so smudged and smeared, and some people question whether it ever corresponded to the territory at all, to now figure out what part of the territory this part of the map was supposed to refer to. I will assume that we have all seen or heard examples of things which are Good, things which are Evil, things which are neither, and things which are somewhere in between. An accurate description of Good & Evil should accurately match those experiences a vast majority (all?) of the time.
It seems to me, that among the clusters of things in possibility space, the core of Good is "to help others at one's own expense" while the core of Evil is "to harm others for one's own benefit".
In my limited attempts at verifying this, the Goodness or Evilness of an action or situation has so far seemed to correlate with the presence, absence, and intensity of these versions of Good & Evil. Situations where one does great harm to others for one's own gain seem clearly evil, like executing political opposition. Situations where one helps others at a cost to oneself seem clearly good, like carrying people out of a burning building. Situations where no harm nor help is done, and no benefit is gained nor cost expended, seem neither Good nor Evil, such as a rock sitting in the sun, doing nothing. Situations where both harm is done & help is given, and where both a cost is expended and a benefit is gained, seem both Good and Evil, or somewhere in between, such as rescuing an unconscious person from a burning building, and then taking their wallet.
The correctness of this explanation depends on whether it matches others' judgements of specific instances of Good or Evil, so I can't really prove its correctness from my armchair. The only counterexamples I have seen so far involved significant amounts of motivated reasoning (someone who was certain that theft wasn't wrong when they did it).
I'm sure there are many things wrong with this, but I can't expect to become better at rationality if I'm not willing to be crappy at it first.
Ok, if you want more realistic examples, consider: