Provisional: a few weeks ago, the LW magic recommendation feed showed me this EY article about bioethics being stupid, from a while back. I was somewhat persuaded by his point. Your random sample seems to strongly confirm his model/hypothesis:
A doctor treating a patient should not try to be academically original, to come up with a brilliant new theory of bioethics. As I’ve written before, ethics is not supposed to be counterintuitive, and yet academic ethicists are biased to be just exactly counterintuitive enough that people won’t say, “Hey, I could have thought of that.” The purpose of ethics is to shape a well-lived life, not to be impressively complicated. Professional ethicists, to get paid, must transform ethics into something difficult enough to require professional ethicists.
Many of these papers seem to be doing exactly that, or to just be arguing with some other bioethicist who is doing that. The pullquotes you put in the body of your post certainly make it look like a diseased discipline. These people are just writing op/eds at each other, as far as I can tell.
I only got about halfway through your post because it all seemed aggressively uninteresting to anyone who is not an academic bioethicist. And I like reading philosophy of religion!
Finally, I think it's totally nuts that people assert that nudges are, or even can be, per se unethical. But I think maybe I need to do a full-on post about that after reading up on the issue. Upon reflection, I'm withdrawing this claim because a) it's not germane to the main post or my comment and b) I'm always complaining in my head about people posting contentious claims on LW without any support, so I shouldn't do that, either.
[edited to add a link to the Diseased Discipline article.]
In fairness, some of the papers appear to have been written by doctors/hospital workers who had a problematic situation (patient was insisting on a bad treatment, refused the right treatments) that they reflected on and had an opinion to share. Doctors thinking about these dilemmas afterwards sounds useful, maybe the "achievement unlocked, papers published +1" gamification incentives them to reflect better on these issues. In theory another doctor might read the paper and learn something they later apply to a similar situation, although my suspicion is thi... (read more)
Some scholarly fields are very healthy (e.g., physics). Some are fairly unhealthy (e.g., evolutionary psychology, sad to say). Some are outright crazy (e.g., philosophy of religion).
How good or bad is bioethics? How rigorous and truth-tracking is it? How much social benefit or harm does it cause?
Looking at lots of random examples is an under-used tool for making progress on this kind of question. It's fast, it avoids the perils of cherry-picking, and it doesn't require you to trust someone else's high-level summary of the field.
I picked the two highest-impact-factor "medical ethics" journals that have the word "bioethics" in the title: The American Journal of Bioethics and Bioethics. Together, these two journals release about 500 reports, book reviews, etc. per year.
I then picked a random article from 2014 through 2020 from each journal, plus extra random articles from the more cited journal (The American Journal of Bioethics): five from 2016, 2018, and 2020, and two from 2017 and 2019.
For each article, I quoted the abstract (if there is one), the first two paragraphs, and the final paragraph. These are provided below, sorted by year.
Obviously this breadth-first approach won't provide a full sense of the quality of argumentation in these papers; but it will hopefully provide a picture of what kinds of views tend to get argued for in the field, what those arguments tend to look like, what tends to get taken for granted, what tends to get ignored, and so on.
I expect more accurate conclusions and faster consensus-building about bioethics if conversation is grounded in a common pool of examples (which can then be drilled down on to spot-check a particular paper's arguments, etc.).
Added: aphyer summarized the articles in the comment section; I've put aphyer's summaries in an editable Google Doc to make it easier to improve on the summaries (and to encourage article-by-article critiques, in the comments below or in the Doc).
2014
1. Against Fetishism About Egalitarianism and in Defense of Cautious Moral Bioenhancement
Ingmar Persson and Julian Savulescu. The American Journal of Bioethics 14(4). Open Peer Commentaries.
2. Why Publishing Pseudonymously Can Protect Academic Freedom
Francesca Minerva. Bioethics 28(4). Symposium: 'Anonymised Publishing in Bioethics'.
2015
3. A Philosophical Misunderstanding at the Basis of Opposition to Nudging
Shlomo Cohen. The American Journal of Bioethics 15(10). Open Peer Commentaries.
4. Why not Commercial Assistance for Suicide? On the Question of Argumentative Coherence of Endorsing Assisted Suicide
Roland Kripke. Bioethics 29(7). Article.
2016
5. One Exemption Too Many: The Case for Mandated CCHD Screening
John D. Lantos, Julie Caciki, and Jeremy R. Garrett. The American Journal of Bioethics 16(1). Guest Editorial.
6. The Curious Case of the De-ICD: Negotiating the Dynamics of Autonomy and Paternalism in Complex Clinical Relationships
Daryl Pullman and Kathleen Hodgkinson. The American Journal of Bioethics 16(8). Article.
7. A Pilot Evaluation of Portfolios for Quality Attestation of Clinical Ethics Consultants
Joseph J. Fins, et al. The American Journal of Bioethics 16(3). Target Article.
8. Research Moratoria and Off-Label Use of Ketamine
Andrea Segal and Dominic Sisti. The American Journal of Bioethics 16(4). Open Peer Commentaries.
9. Good Ethics Begin With Good Facts
Birgitta Sujdak Mackiewicz. The American Journal of Bioethics 16(7). Case Commentaries.
10. The Ethics of Organ Donor Registration Policies: Nudges and Respect for Autonomy
Douglas MacKay and Alexandra Robinson. The American Journal of Bioethics 16(11). Target Article.
11. A Trust‐Based Pact in Research Biobanks. From Theory to Practice
Virginia Sanchini, et al. Bioethics 30(4). Original Article.
2017
12. Responsible Translation of Psychiatric Genetics and Other Neuroscience Developments: In Need of Empirical Bioethics Research
Gabriel Lázaro-Muñoz. The American Journal of Bioethics 17(4). Open Peer Commentaries.
13. Interconnectedness and Interdependence: Challenges for Public Health Ethics
Jonathan Beever and Nicolae Morar. The American Journal of Bioethics 17(9). Open Peer Commentaries.
14. Expanded Access for Nusinersen in Patients With Spinal Muscular Atropy: Negotiating Limited Data, Limited Alternative Treatments, and Limited Hospital Resources
Benjamin S. Wilfond, Christian Morales, and Holly A. Taylor. The American Journal of Bioethics 17(10). Case Report.
15. The Consequences of Vagueness in Consent to Organ Donation
David M. Shaw. Bioethics 31(6). Original Article.
2018
16. A Model for Communication About Longshot Treatments in the Context of Early Access to Unapproved, Investigational Drugs
Eline M. Bunnik and Nikkie Aarts. The American Journal of Bioethics 18(1). Open Peer Commentaries
17. Enhance Diversity Among Researchers to Promote Participant Trust in Precision Medicine Research
Demetrio Sierra-Mercado and Gabriel Lázaro-Muñoz. The American Journal of Bioethics 18(4). Open Peer Commentaries.
18. Miracles, Scarce Resources, and Fairness
Steve Clarke. The American Journal of Bioethics 18(5). Open Peer Commentaries.
19. Conscience as a Civil and Criminal Defense
Nadia N. Sawicki. The American Journal of Bioethics 18(7). Open Peer Commentaries.
20. The “Reasonable Subject Standard” as an Alternative to the “Best Interest Standard”
Joseph Millum. The American Journal of Bioethics 18(8). Open Peer Commentaries.
21. Keep It Simple
John J. Paris and Brian M. Cummings. The American Journal of Bioethics 18(8). Open Peer Commentary.
22. Not a matter of parental choice but of social justice obligation: Children are owed measles vaccination
Johan C. Bester. Bioethics 32(9). Original Article.
2019
23. Rational Freedom and Six Mistakes of a Bioconservative
Julian Savulescu. The American Journal of Bioethics 19(7). Editorials.
24. The Exploitation of Professional “Guinea Pigs” in the Gig Economy: The Difficult Road From Consent to Justice
Roberto Abadie. The American Journal of Bioethics 19(9). Open Peer Commentaries.
25. Caring for Dying Children
Edwin N. Forman and Rosalind Ekman Ladd. The American Journal of Bioethics 19(12). Open Peer Commentaries.
26. Research versus practice: The dilemmas of research ethics in the era of learning health‐care systems
Jan Piasecki and Vilius Dranseika. Bioethics 33(5). Original Article.
2020
27. “Unusual Care”: Groupthink and Willful Blindness in the SUPPORT Study
George J. Annas and Catherine L. Annas. The American Journal of Bioethics 20(1). Open Peer Commentaries.
28. From Solo Decision Maker to Multi-Stakeholder Process: A Defense and Recommendations
David Ozar, et al. The American Journal of Bioethics 20(2). Open Peer Commentaries.
29. The Healthcare Ethics Consultant-Certified Program: Fair, Feasible, and Defensible, But Neither Definitive Nor Finished
Armand H. Matheny Antommaria, et al. The American Journal of Bioethics 20(3). Guest Editorials.
30. A Call for Diversity and Inclusivity in the HEC-C Program
Julie Aultman and Cynthia Pathmathasan. The American Journal of Bioethics 20(3). Open Peer Commentaries.
31. To Be Coherently Beneficient, Be Communitarian
Charles Foster. The American Journal of Bioethics 20(3). Open Peer Commentaries.
32. The Case Against Solicitation of Consent for Apnea Testing
Dhristie Bhagat and Ariane Lewis. The American Journal of Bioethics 20(6). Open Peer Commentaries
33. THE TRUSTED DOCTOR: MEDICAL ETHICS AND PROFESSIONALISM
Philip Charles Hébert. Bioethics 34(9). Book Review.