Every once in a while, I encounter what I call the idiot’s reductio: “If you truly believed X, you’d do Y. Since you don’t do Y, you must not actually believe X.”
A special case is when people say “I don’t believe in/feel/have X. But if you truly did believe in X, you’d do a crazy and absurd thing. Since you don’t do this crazy and absurd thing, I conclude you don’t believe in X, and also X isn’t real.”
Almost always incredibly childish and a complete failure of theory of mind. Some examples:
If you actually believed in the Christian Bible, you’d avoid wearing mixed fibers. Therefore you’re a fake Christian and you should either be an atheist or believe in my specific flavor of liberal Christianity with no controversial components.
God is the only reason for human morality. If not for Christianity, people would murder their neighbors all the time. Therefore your atheism is fake and the Christian God is real.
If you actually thought abortion was murder, you’d firebomb a Walmart, and hold funerals for miscarriages. You haven’t firebombed a Walmart. QED.
If you actually thought factory farming is evil, you’d firebomb a Walmart.
If you actually believed in climate change, you’d firebomb a Walmart.
If you actually believed in AI doom, you’d firebomb a Walmart.
If Al Gore really believed in climate change, he wouldn’t fly to climate change conferences and would, I dunno, swim or something.
If you really believed in open borders, you’d leave your front door unlocked and house migrants yourself.
Erika Kirk does speeches and sometimes laughs on camera in interviews. Therefore, she’s not actually sad about her husband dying. Also the death was faked.
“She called her alleged rapist the day after, therefore she wasn’t raped.”
“If you actually believed in Communism you wouldn’t be using an iPhone”
“If Ayn Rand was a real capitalist, she wouldn’t take welfare”
When Jacob Coxon quit Anthropic to warn the world about AI doom, he got a cacophony of comments about how if he’s actually worried he’d stay and try to make AI safer from the inside.
When Evan, head of misalignment science at Anthropic, said he’s extremely worried and that’s why he’s staying and trying to make it better, the peanut gallery immediately pivoted to saying his beliefs must be fake because otherwise he would’ve quit.
Quitting is evidence of fake beliefs, and so is staying. It seems like the masters of the idiot’s reductio are conveniently always impervious to evidence!
When I wrote my recent, measured post about near-term AI doom and pivoting to pausing AI, I immediately got dozens of aggro comments about how I should either spend my last year to convince randos of milquetoast positions on alignment, or chill out in San Diego or something. Implicit: therefore your beliefs are fake.
I’m sure you’ve encountered the same.
I used to think the core issue was a failure to appreciate human differences while modeling other people. Everybody approaches grief/fear/dread/betrayal/worries about humanity’s extinction in different ways. Perhaps people weren’t previously aware of this?
I used to think that, but I now think the explanation is too clean, and ironically overly charitable. After thinking about it some and observing more examples in the wild, I think the failure is even worse than that: most people making the idiot’s reductio don’t even have enough imagination to model *their own* minds. Or worse, they have that imagination but choose not to use it.
For example, if somebody says that God is the only reason that people don’t go around murdering their neighbors, I used to buy into the belief that those specific people have broken moral compasses and don’t understand how other people can have moral commitments without a divine arbitrator. But I thought about it just a tiny bit more, and realized that if those specific people de-converted, it seems unlikely they’d go around murdering people. So not only do they lack a plausible other-people-model, they also lack a coherent self-model.
Similarly, when people are like “if you really believed in AI doom, you’d commit mass violence,” I used to think the only people who’d say this are psychopaths who really want to firebomb a Walmart, have minimal concept of cause and effect, are just itching for an excuse, and also incapable of modeling other people’s saner reactions.
A perfectly fine, unbombed, Walmart. Photo by Zack Yeo on Unsplash
But I thought about it a little bit more, and realized that of course the same people are, in addition to having poor ability/willingness to model cause and effect and other people, also (thankfully) low-agency, nonviolent, incapable of doing real stuff, etc. They, too, will not firebomb a Walmart.
So the people who make the strange modus tollens move of “I don’t believe in/feel/have X. But if you truly did believe in X, you’d do this crazy and ridiculous and absurd thing. Since you don’t do this crazy and ridiculous and absurd thing, I conclude that not only is X false, but you also don’t believe it” sure seem off – my tentative conclusion is that they have either severely diminished reasoning faculties or severely diminished willingness to use reason, even more so than I previously thought.
I’m not sure what the best response is in those circumstances. Two good options that come to mind are:
A short, high-minded response, aimed at onlookers. “I don’t think Y is the best solution to X. Here’s what I do instead.” Limit it to 1-3 sentences.
(verbal equivalent of) Honest laughter at the idiot’s reductio for being as honestly idiotic as it actually is. “Wait, wait, you’re telling me that the best way for me to reduce abortions in America is firebombing a Walmart? What a wise and moral strategy! Why didn’t I think of that?”
Bonus points if you can laugh with your interlocutor rather than at them (maintaining the polite social fiction that this is an honest slip-up on their end), though that isn’t strictly required.
But either way, you should mostly not waste your time. Don’t make the mistake of taking the idiot’s reductio, or the people who voice it, seriously. “The discourse” is not real life!
Btw I remember seeing a meme on Twitter that illustrates this perfectly (I think it had a line about "sumptuous babies" or something). I was unable to find it for this post. Please link it or post it if you know where to find it! :)
Subtitle: if you truly believed that...
Every once in a while, I encounter what I call the idiot’s reductio: “If you truly believed X, you’d do Y. Since you don’t do Y, you must not actually believe X.”
A special case is when people say “I don’t believe in/feel/have X. But if you truly did believe in X, you’d do a crazy and absurd thing. Since you don’t do this crazy and absurd thing, I conclude you don’t believe in X, and also X isn’t real.”
Almost always incredibly childish and a complete failure of theory of mind. Some examples:
I’m sure you’ve encountered the same.
I used to think the core issue was a failure to appreciate human differences while modeling other people. Everybody approaches grief/fear/dread/betrayal/worries about humanity’s extinction in different ways. Perhaps people weren’t previously aware of this?
I used to think that, but I now think the explanation is too clean, and ironically overly charitable. After thinking about it some and observing more examples in the wild, I think the failure is even worse than that: most people making the idiot’s reductio don’t even have enough imagination to model *their own* minds. Or worse, they have that imagination but choose not to use it.
For example, if somebody says that God is the only reason that people don’t go around murdering their neighbors, I used to buy into the belief that those specific people have broken moral compasses and don’t understand how other people can have moral commitments without a divine arbitrator. But I thought about it just a tiny bit more, and realized that if those specific people de-converted, it seems unlikely they’d go around murdering people. So not only do they lack a plausible other-people-model, they also lack a coherent self-model.
Similarly, when people are like “if you really believed in AI doom, you’d commit mass violence,” I used to think the only people who’d say this are psychopaths who really want to firebomb a Walmart, have minimal concept of cause and effect, are just itching for an excuse, and also incapable of modeling other people’s saner reactions.
A perfectly fine, unbombed, Walmart. Photo by Zack Yeo on Unsplash
But I thought about it a little bit more, and realized that of course the same people are, in addition to having poor ability/willingness to model cause and effect and other people, also (thankfully) low-agency, nonviolent, incapable of doing real stuff, etc. They, too, will not firebomb a Walmart.
So the people who make the strange modus tollens move of “I don’t believe in/feel/have X. But if you truly did believe in X, you’d do this crazy and ridiculous and absurd thing. Since you don’t do this crazy and ridiculous and absurd thing, I conclude that not only is X false, but you also don’t believe it” sure seem off – my tentative conclusion is that they have either severely diminished reasoning faculties or severely diminished willingness to use reason, even more so than I previously thought.
I’m not sure what the best response is in those circumstances. Two good options that come to mind are:
But either way, you should mostly not waste your time. Don’t make the mistake of taking the idiot’s reductio, or the people who voice it, seriously. “The discourse” is not real life!