LESSWRONG
LW

patrik-cihal's Shortform

by patrik-cihal
7th May 2025
1 min read
5

1

This is a special post for quick takes by patrik-cihal. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
patrik-cihal's Shortform
1patrik-cihal
1patrik-cihal
2Dagon
2cubefox
1patrik-cihal
-1[comment deleted]
5 comments, sorted by
top scoring
Click to highlight new comments since: Today at 12:48 AM
[-]patrik-cihal20h10

It's very hard to imagine humans prosper in a world with AGIs. What's the point of solving the alignment problem? Is it so that one ASI can create a civilization where AGIs will never exist and then self-destruct?

Reply
[-]patrik-cihal4mo10

I don't like the term map, because it communicates something static. But the real world is not static. It evolves dynamically. Sure there are things in life which are for which I guess it is good to use the term, for instance mathematical theorems, physical laws, etc... But does anyone have a better term for the real world. Something like current-world-state. So that I could still say "my idea of current world state corresponds to the real world state" but shorter?

Reply
[-]Dagon4mo20

I think with modern interactive navigation support, the static implication of "map" is probably going away anyway.  But to be clear, the POINT of the map-territory metaphor is that the map CANNOT be perfect, both because it's less detailed, but also because it can't change at the same rate as the world.

The real world is quite dynamic.  Our mental models and descriptions of the world are less dynamic than the world itself. 

Reply
[-]cubefox4mo20

Beliefs? World model?

Reply
[-]patrik-cihal4mo10

not as nice as map corresponding to territory tho

Reply
[+][comment deleted]2mo-10
Moderation Log
More from patrik-cihal
View more
Curated and popular this week
5Comments
Deleted by patrik-cihal, 06/30/2025