(This is not a post about epistemics, or AI doom arguments, or making a case for any specific beliefs. It's been written about plenty and I'm not going to spend the time it would take to do it justice. This post takes for granted that, while I have high uncertainty and I obviously hope that we're enormously wrong about the risks of AI, I am taking it seriously, and it's scary.)
It feels like it's been a long time coming. I've been reading Lesswrong for, like, half my life? In 2015, after years of agonizing, I left ICU nursing, the job of my dreams, that I'd been working toward since I was fourteen, because some people whose opinions I respected made sufficiently compelling arguments that the world was in trouble, and that maybe my contribution could matter.
I think they weren't wrong. It sure seems like it matters now. I mean, it still feels arrogant to say so, but here I am, working 50 hours a week on those grounds, missing precious moments of my daughter's childhood and spending obscene amounts of money on childcare, and nobody has actually made the case to me that I'm wrong about that calculation.
Less than a year ago, at the Berkeley 2025 Solstice, I gave the following speech.
To my daughter Iomedae
In a week you’ll be twenty months old. I don’t know what you think of this whole existence. You don’t yet have the words to tell me. But I know that you smile easily. You like sauerkraut and olives and kale stew. You charm strangers in airports. In September you swam in the ocean, fearlessly, shrieking with joy in the waves.
I think you’re happy, most of the time. I know that you’re perfect in every way and I love you more than anything.
At night when you’re asleep, I fret about keeping up at work. About our right to be in this country. Things keep happening on the news, and I don’t like them. I’m terrified for the future of the world, and most of the time it’s too big to look at, but it’s always there in the background.
But in the morning you wake me with your sweet babble, and reach for me with your little arms, and it’s good, and perfect, and nothing can take that away from me.
I want you to get to live forever. I want to see you grow up and be so incredibly cool, and I want to be proud of whatever it is you do, and I want you to have all the resources I can offer you to be whoever you want to be.
I don’t know if you get to live to be ten.
I wish I could protect you; I wish I could fix everything for you. I do what I can, or at least I try. It’s not very much, though I do take some personal pride in the beautifully organized state of Lighthaven’s finances. Even if I knew all the right things to do, which I don’t, I’ve learned the hard way that I can’t just use willpower to be some other person with personality traits better suited to the work at hand. Your glorious perfection doesn’t, actually, make me perfect.
Sometimes I worry it was selfish to have you. I’ve wanted a child since I was sixteen years old, and having a baby to fill your unmet emotional needs raises some red flags. Sometimes my Internet friends debate whether it’s ethical to bring a person into the world at all, when you can’t ask their consent beforehand and they might well end up wishing you hadn’t.
And yet most parents from history would look at our house and see wealth and opportunity beyond wonder. On the larger stage, events happen at a terrifying and unprecedented speed and I feel like the world stopped making sense sometime in my late 20s, but I shift my focus to look at our street, our village, and - it’s good.
I didn’t get to ask your permission, but I chose this. I chose you, wholeheartedly, and I want to savor every second. I want to drink in every perfect moment that, no matter what the future holds, can’t be unmade. To siphon off a little of that joy, every day, filling up a secret reservoir that had been drained for years before I had you in my life. I tell myself that having you makes me stronger, and maybe, if someday I need to do something very very hard because one can make an argument that it’s the right thing to do and I’m the best person to do it, maybe I can draw on that strength.
I think you’re happy, most of the time. I know that I love you more than anything, and tomorrow you’ll wake me with your sweet babble, and that moment will be good and right and perfect and nothing will ever take that away.
If someday I need to do something very very hard because one can make an argument that it’s the right thing to do and I’m the best person to do it, maybe I can draw on that strength.
If, I said.
I didn't expect that 'if' to arrive before the next Solstice.
I am not okay with this. I am not resigned. But I've already done a lot of processing.
I was depressed for years. I had suicidal thoughts over my feelings of inadequacy at how poor a job I was doing at fixing the world's biggest problems, and at the same time I missed ICU nursing and bitterly resented leaving. I have crammed such an unbelievable quantity of angst about not wanting to be ambitious into the last decade. I did my processing and my grieving over years, mostly via writing my own 1.7 million word take on a Mercedes Lackey fantasy trilogy from the 90s about it[2].
I learned about a cancer diagnosis, and stared at the various 5-year mortality rates, and that was all the way back in 2020. Then I went into journalism, and got to spend a year with it being literally my job to read all the most deeply upsetting news. I processed my angst into a sprawling set of wish-fulfillment stories where my self-insert got to do all the shiny ICU medicine in an actually functional healthcare system, in an actually functional world, never needing to worry about whether she should be doing something more important[3].
I spent nearly a decade desperately wanting a baby, however conflicted I thought I was supposed to feel about the cost to my career or the ethics of bringing a child into such an uncertain world. I wrote a story about being the daughter whose mother knew she lived in a doomed world, and had her anyway.
Before any of that, I was an ICU nurse. I watched human beings die, in front of me, enough times that I no longer remember exactly how many.[4]
Last November, I went out for breakfast with a colleague after our last night shift. It had been an awful night for her–struggling to keep her patient alive till the morning, the inexperienced resident scared shitless, every nurse on the unit hanging around the room staring at the monitor.
The patient died at 7:45 am. My colleague finished charting, and we went out and ate a huge greasy diner breakfast and drank endless decaf coffee, and we told all our most horrific stories, and we laughed. Yeah. We laughed.
And one of the things that really makes it sink in, how many problems there are in the world, is that learning to laugh at the horror is one hundred percent necessary. It’s maybe one of the healthiest coping mechanisms, healthier than alcohol or even greasy diner breakfasts. It was the best way I knew to take what I saw at work, and somehow accept it and then move on.
So I gave up my day’s sleep to sit with my colleague and friend, and laugh so we could postpone the tears. Later I cried. And it was right, to feel sad for the person who just died, who was someone’s mother, someone’s sister, someone’s friend. I wanted to grieve, even if she wasn’t my family, even if I knew next to nothing aside from her name and age.
We stood outside the patient’s room at 7:45 am, exhausted after 12 hours, and watched her heart rate drop farther and farther until it was just an occasional ventricular beat. Watched the blood pressure go down to 30/10, which at that point is not really a blood pressure anymore, before we lost it entirely. She had a do-not-resuscitate order, and was already maxed on every vasopressor and we were running epinephrine at five times the supposed maximum dose, and we knew there was no winning this one–we had known it for days, really. You can’t save them all.
It’s been over a year, and I can still see that scene perfectly in my head. I don’t remember all of my patients, by any stretch of the imagination. But I remember the ones we couldn’t save.
I had a lady once for five 12-hour shifts. She had advanced chronic lung disease; she had been on home oxygen for years; and she was back in the ICU for the second time that year, on a ventilator, sedated. Her friend and maybe-lover came to see her every day, and sat by her bedside to talk to her, and asked me if I knew when she’d be coming back so he could get her room ready. It was one of the sweetest things I had ever seen.
She was my ‘boring’ patient that week. She got maybe a third of my time. I strained my back trying to turn her alone. Once I left her in a soiled bed for hours before I could find a second nurse to help me clean her. I put dressings on her inevitable bedsores, and I tried to make sure she wasn’t in pain.
Maybe three weeks later, I had two other patients and was run off my feet and stopped midafternoon at the nursing station, and I saw that her heart rate was 30. I glanced over, and knew immediately that she was palliative, that they were going to take her off the ventilator and switch her to comfort care only.
I didn’t have time to watch; she wasn’t my patient. But I did anyway, stood outside the room where she was alone, and watched her heart stop, and I wanted to say, I’m sorry. I’m sorry I called you my boring patient. I’m sorry I didn’t love you more. Fellow human, I want you to know that I know this is wrong, even though it’s the least wrong option. That for the last ten years you were slowly losing your strength, tethered to your oxygen, and the last three weeks of your life were spent helpless in a bed, surrounded by beeping machines, and that now there’s nothing more we can offer you except for a death without pain… We gave you our best, every step of the way, but that doesn’t make it right. I’m sorry that humans still have to get old and die. I’m sorry that I didn’t have the courage to go into the room with you and hold your hand, because you weren’t my patient and it would’ve looked weird and I didn’t have time.
The memory is hazy now. I’ve forgotten her name. I can’t even wrap my head around the tragedy of that one death. And we lose two more people every second. We’ve lost another sixty million since her. Gone, just like that. We can’t save them all. And we can’t take the time to grieve for them the way we ought to – so we laugh, and look away, and keep moving forward.
Because one thing I know is that we can’t afford to stop.
I am not okay about the world or its future, and I am not resigned, and I don't think it makes sense for me, right now, to make time to grieve it, when I have done so much fucking grieving already.
To start with: what time, exactly? I have a job! I have a toddler! I have a ridiculous supernatural medical drama novel I'm not finished editing. I have Wednesday night neighborhood dinners to pick up cooking for again whenever I can manage it.
I don't think I've ever been any good at sitting down on purpose to deliberately process grief anyway. It's hard to imagine an amount of staring that would get me to, what, acceptance? Of the fact that my child may not live long enough to start kindergarten? I wrote a Solstice speech for that one too. For most of history, that was what mothers could expect for halfof their children. It was an upbeat speech, but I cried writing it[5]. I made my unhappiest self-insert deal with a lot worse.
And grieving the possible extinction of humanity, not just 'someday, but maybe, conceivably, as soon as next year...
Nope. I'm too busy. I mostly feel very little temptation to spend my limited free time on doomscrolling, and I don't think it's worth re-opening the trapdoor to the bottomless pit of this-isn't-what-I-wanted just to stare at it, when I could stare at pictures of my beautiful perfect child instead.
I do intend to try to leave myself time to decompress, because it wouldn't be very strategic of me to disastrously burn out in the next month. I'll make allowances and be gentle with myself when I inevitably end up angsting until 3 am, and I will grieve, whether or not I plan time for it. That's fine.
I am absolutely going to take every moment I have left, every moment I can squeeze into every day, to love my daughter. I could have died of cancer in 2021, and she would never have existed. Every perfect moment we have is one that didn't have to happen.
I still wouldn't call myself ambitious. I still have the same old worn-out angst that maybe if I was worse at things, I wouldn't have quite so many things to do, and I could pick the ones that exult my soul without abandoning more important responsibilities. But I've managed to grow some very specific ambitions. I'd like the accounting done right. Sounds like a nice support-role sidekick project, right? Well, I work for Oliver Habryka, so I think it's going to take some ambition to pull it off.
I think my daughter is happy, most of the time. Deciding to have her is one thing I don't feel conflicted about at all.[6] I want her to have a world to grow up in, and there are tasks in front of me that might help.
I was originally going to go find ten links to recent news for each word in this sentence, and concluded that another thing I don't feel like making time for right now is going back and rereading depressing blog posts.
On the topic of processing via fictional analogies: in book 11 of A Song for Two Voices, the Existential Bad Outcome that the characters have been staring down for twenty years very abruptly escalates, things start happening relentlessly, and the rest plays out over roughly a month. Lately I catch myself wondering how I'll know when I'm in this timeline's Book 11. I don't think we're in book 11 of ASFTV quite yet, but I'm not 100% sure we aren't, and it feels like I maybe just didn't think to write the version of book 11 where it felt hard to be sure if it was really that serious and also it might play out over multiple years. Anyway: hi there, Final Books Of ASFTV Feeling. It's nice to have a shared reference for you.
I started to write a version of this sentence including 'and no one ever tells her she needs to be more ambitious', before remembering that that's completely false.
I'm pretty sure my job would not be getting any more productivity out of me if I didn't have a toddler. Sure, it takes time to parent her, but I waste so much less time on being sad at my lack of BABY. Also, she's objectively perfect in every way, and this includes being pretty easy to parent.
There sure has been a lot of bad news lately.[1]
(This is not a post about epistemics, or AI doom arguments, or making a case for any specific beliefs. It's been written about plenty and I'm not going to spend the time it would take to do it justice. This post takes for granted that, while I have high uncertainty and I obviously hope that we're enormously wrong about the risks of AI, I am taking it seriously, and it's scary.)
It feels like it's been a long time coming. I've been reading Lesswrong for, like, half my life? In 2015, after years of agonizing, I left ICU nursing, the job of my dreams, that I'd been working toward since I was fourteen, because some people whose opinions I respected made sufficiently compelling arguments that the world was in trouble, and that maybe my contribution could matter.
I think they weren't wrong. It sure seems like it matters now. I mean, it still feels arrogant to say so, but here I am, working 50 hours a week on those grounds, missing precious moments of my daughter's childhood and spending obscene amounts of money on childcare, and nobody has actually made the case to me that I'm wrong about that calculation.
Less than a year ago, at the Berkeley 2025 Solstice, I gave the following speech.
To my daughter Iomedae
In a week you’ll be twenty months old. I don’t know what you think of this whole existence. You don’t yet have the words to tell me. But I know that you smile easily. You like sauerkraut and olives and kale stew. You charm strangers in airports. In September you swam in the ocean, fearlessly, shrieking with joy in the waves.
I think you’re happy, most of the time. I know that you’re perfect in every way and I love you more than anything.
At night when you’re asleep, I fret about keeping up at work. About our right to be in this country. Things keep happening on the news, and I don’t like them. I’m terrified for the future of the world, and most of the time it’s too big to look at, but it’s always there in the background.
But in the morning you wake me with your sweet babble, and reach for me with your little arms, and it’s good, and perfect, and nothing can take that away from me.
I want you to get to live forever. I want to see you grow up and be so incredibly cool, and I want to be proud of whatever it is you do, and I want you to have all the resources I can offer you to be whoever you want to be.
I don’t know if you get to live to be ten.
I wish I could protect you; I wish I could fix everything for you. I do what I can, or at least I try. It’s not very much, though I do take some personal pride in the beautifully organized state of Lighthaven’s finances. Even if I knew all the right things to do, which I don’t, I’ve learned the hard way that I can’t just use willpower to be some other person with personality traits better suited to the work at hand. Your glorious perfection doesn’t, actually, make me perfect.
Sometimes I worry it was selfish to have you. I’ve wanted a child since I was sixteen years old, and having a baby to fill your unmet emotional needs raises some red flags. Sometimes my Internet friends debate whether it’s ethical to bring a person into the world at all, when you can’t ask their consent beforehand and they might well end up wishing you hadn’t.
And yet most parents from history would look at our house and see wealth and opportunity beyond wonder. On the larger stage, events happen at a terrifying and unprecedented speed and I feel like the world stopped making sense sometime in my late 20s, but I shift my focus to look at our street, our village, and - it’s good.
I didn’t get to ask your permission, but I chose this. I chose you, wholeheartedly, and I want to savor every second. I want to drink in every perfect moment that, no matter what the future holds, can’t be unmade. To siphon off a little of that joy, every day, filling up a secret reservoir that had been drained for years before I had you in my life. I tell myself that having you makes me stronger, and maybe, if someday I need to do something very very hard because one can make an argument that it’s the right thing to do and I’m the best person to do it, maybe I can draw on that strength.
I think you’re happy, most of the time. I know that I love you more than anything, and tomorrow you’ll wake me with your sweet babble, and that moment will be good and right and perfect and nothing will ever take that away.
If someday I need to do something very very hard because one can make an argument that it’s the right thing to do and I’m the best person to do it, maybe I can draw on that strength.
If, I said.
I didn't expect that 'if' to arrive before the next Solstice.
I am not okay with this. I am not resigned. But I've already done a lot of processing.
I was depressed for years. I had suicidal thoughts over my feelings of inadequacy at how poor a job I was doing at fixing the world's biggest problems, and at the same time I missed ICU nursing and bitterly resented leaving. I have crammed such an unbelievable quantity of angst about not wanting to be ambitious into the last decade. I did my processing and my grieving over years, mostly via writing my own 1.7 million word take on a Mercedes Lackey fantasy trilogy from the 90s about it[2].
I learned about a cancer diagnosis, and stared at the various 5-year mortality rates, and that was all the way back in 2020. Then I went into journalism, and got to spend a year with it being literally my job to read all the most deeply upsetting news. I processed my angst into a sprawling set of wish-fulfillment stories where my self-insert got to do all the shiny ICU medicine in an actually functional healthcare system, in an actually functional world, never needing to worry about whether she should be doing something more important[3].
I spent nearly a decade desperately wanting a baby, however conflicted I thought I was supposed to feel about the cost to my career or the ethics of bringing a child into such an uncertain world. I wrote a story about being the daughter whose mother knew she lived in a doomed world, and had her anyway.
Before any of that, I was an ICU nurse. I watched human beings die, in front of me, enough times that I no longer remember exactly how many.[4]
I gave a different Solstice speech about it once.
Last November, I went out for breakfast with a colleague after our last night shift. It had been an awful night for her–struggling to keep her patient alive till the morning, the inexperienced resident scared shitless, every nurse on the unit hanging around the room staring at the monitor.
The patient died at 7:45 am. My colleague finished charting, and we went out and ate a huge greasy diner breakfast and drank endless decaf coffee, and we told all our most horrific stories, and we laughed. Yeah. We laughed.
And one of the things that really makes it sink in, how many problems there are in the world, is that learning to laugh at the horror is one hundred percent necessary. It’s maybe one of the healthiest coping mechanisms, healthier than alcohol or even greasy diner breakfasts. It was the best way I knew to take what I saw at work, and somehow accept it and then move on.
So I gave up my day’s sleep to sit with my colleague and friend, and laugh so we could postpone the tears. Later I cried. And it was right, to feel sad for the person who just died, who was someone’s mother, someone’s sister, someone’s friend. I wanted to grieve, even if she wasn’t my family, even if I knew next to nothing aside from her name and age.
We stood outside the patient’s room at 7:45 am, exhausted after 12 hours, and watched her heart rate drop farther and farther until it was just an occasional ventricular beat. Watched the blood pressure go down to 30/10, which at that point is not really a blood pressure anymore, before we lost it entirely. She had a do-not-resuscitate order, and was already maxed on every vasopressor and we were running epinephrine at five times the supposed maximum dose, and we knew there was no winning this one–we had known it for days, really. You can’t save them all.
It’s been over a year, and I can still see that scene perfectly in my head. I don’t remember all of my patients, by any stretch of the imagination. But I remember the ones we couldn’t save.
I had a lady once for five 12-hour shifts. She had advanced chronic lung disease; she had been on home oxygen for years; and she was back in the ICU for the second time that year, on a ventilator, sedated. Her friend and maybe-lover came to see her every day, and sat by her bedside to talk to her, and asked me if I knew when she’d be coming back so he could get her room ready. It was one of the sweetest things I had ever seen.
She was my ‘boring’ patient that week. She got maybe a third of my time. I strained my back trying to turn her alone. Once I left her in a soiled bed for hours before I could find a second nurse to help me clean her. I put dressings on her inevitable bedsores, and I tried to make sure she wasn’t in pain.
Maybe three weeks later, I had two other patients and was run off my feet and stopped midafternoon at the nursing station, and I saw that her heart rate was 30. I glanced over, and knew immediately that she was palliative, that they were going to take her off the ventilator and switch her to comfort care only.
I didn’t have time to watch; she wasn’t my patient. But I did anyway, stood outside the room where she was alone, and watched her heart stop, and I wanted to say, I’m sorry. I’m sorry I called you my boring patient. I’m sorry I didn’t love you more. Fellow human, I want you to know that I know this is wrong, even though it’s the least wrong option. That for the last ten years you were slowly losing your strength, tethered to your oxygen, and the last three weeks of your life were spent helpless in a bed, surrounded by beeping machines, and that now there’s nothing more we can offer you except for a death without pain… We gave you our best, every step of the way, but that doesn’t make it right. I’m sorry that humans still have to get old and die. I’m sorry that I didn’t have the courage to go into the room with you and hold your hand, because you weren’t my patient and it would’ve looked weird and I didn’t have time.
The memory is hazy now. I’ve forgotten her name. I can’t even wrap my head around the tragedy of that one death. And we lose two more people every second. We’ve lost another sixty million since her. Gone, just like that. We can’t save them all. And we can’t take the time to grieve for them the way we ought to – so we laugh, and look away, and keep moving forward.
Because one thing I know is that we can’t afford to stop.
I am not okay about the world or its future, and I am not resigned, and I don't think it makes sense for me, right now, to make time to grieve it, when I have done so much fucking grieving already.
To start with: what time, exactly? I have a job! I have a toddler! I have a ridiculous supernatural medical drama novel I'm not finished editing. I have Wednesday night neighborhood dinners to pick up cooking for again whenever I can manage it.
I don't think I've ever been any good at sitting down on purpose to deliberately process grief anyway. It's hard to imagine an amount of staring that would get me to, what, acceptance? Of the fact that my child may not live long enough to start kindergarten? I wrote a Solstice speech for that one too. For most of history, that was what mothers could expect for half of their children. It was an upbeat speech, but I cried writing it[5]. I made my unhappiest self-insert deal with a lot worse.
And grieving the possible extinction of humanity, not just 'someday, but maybe, conceivably, as soon as next year...
Nope. I'm too busy. I mostly feel very little temptation to spend my limited free time on doomscrolling, and I don't think it's worth re-opening the trapdoor to the bottomless pit of this-isn't-what-I-wanted just to stare at it, when I could stare at pictures of my beautiful perfect child instead.
I do intend to try to leave myself time to decompress, because it wouldn't be very strategic of me to disastrously burn out in the next month. I'll make allowances and be gentle with myself when I inevitably end up angsting until 3 am, and I will grieve, whether or not I plan time for it. That's fine.
I am absolutely going to take every moment I have left, every moment I can squeeze into every day, to love my daughter. I could have died of cancer in 2021, and she would never have existed. Every perfect moment we have is one that didn't have to happen.
I still wouldn't call myself ambitious. I still have the same old worn-out angst that maybe if I was worse at things, I wouldn't have quite so many things to do, and I could pick the ones that exult my soul without abandoning more important responsibilities. But I've managed to grow some very specific ambitions. I'd like the accounting done right. Sounds like a nice support-role sidekick project, right? Well, I work for Oliver Habryka, so I think it's going to take some ambition to pull it off.
I think my daughter is happy, most of the time. Deciding to have her is one thing I don't feel conflicted about at all.[6] I want her to have a world to grow up in, and there are tasks in front of me that might help.
I was originally going to go find ten links to recent news for each word in this sentence, and concluded that another thing I don't feel like making time for right now is going back and rereading depressing blog posts.
On the topic of processing via fictional analogies: in book 11 of A Song for Two Voices, the Existential Bad Outcome that the characters have been staring down for twenty years very abruptly escalates, things start happening relentlessly, and the rest plays out over roughly a month. Lately I catch myself wondering how I'll know when I'm in this timeline's Book 11. I don't think we're in book 11 of ASFTV quite yet, but I'm not 100% sure we aren't, and it feels like I maybe just didn't think to write the version of book 11 where it felt hard to be sure if it was really that serious and also it might play out over multiple years. Anyway: hi there, Final Books Of ASFTV Feeling. It's nice to have a shared reference for you.
I started to write a version of this sentence including 'and no one ever tells her she needs to be more ambitious', before remembering that that's completely false.
I once attended a CFAR retreat on grieving, and oh my god was that a terrible mistake when I had a shift back in the trauma ICU in Reno the next day.
Admittedly this might be mostly the being five months pregnant at the time.
I'm pretty sure my job would not be getting any more productivity out of me if I didn't have a toddler. Sure, it takes time to parent her, but I waste so much less time on being sad at my lack of BABY. Also, she's objectively perfect in every way, and this includes being pretty easy to parent.