More than half of the authors to this site who have posted more than 10 posts, about you, in particular. Eliezer, Scott Alexander, Jacob Falkovich, Elizabeth Van Nostrand, me, dozens of others. This is not a rare position. I would have to dig to give you an exact list, but the list is not short, and it includes large fractions of almost everyone who one might consider strong contributors to the site.
I see, thanks.
maybe you should just stay out of these conversations
Am I to take this as a statement of a moderation decision, or merely your personal opinion?
If the former—then, of course, I hear and obey. (However, for the remainder of this comment I’ll assume that it’s the latter.)
A good start, if you actually wanted to understand any of this at all, would be to stop strawmaning these people repeatedly by inserting random ellipses and question marks and random snide remarks implying the absurdity of their position.
No, I don’t think that I’m strawmanning anything. You keep saying this, and then your supposed corrections just restate what I’ve said, except with different valence. For instance:
Yes, shockingly, people have preferences about how people interact with them that go beyond obvious unambigious norm violations, what a shocker!
This seems to be just another way to describe what I wrote in the grandparent, except that your description has the connotation of something fine and reasonable and unproblematic, whereas mine obviously does not.
Of course people have such preferences! Indeed, it’s not shocking at all! People prefer not to have their bad ideas challenged, they prefer not to have obvious gaps in their reasoning pointed out, they prefer that people treat all of their utterances as deserving of nothing less than “curious”, “kind”, “collaborative” replies (rather than pointed questions, direct and un-veiled criticism, and a general “trial by fire”, “explore it by trying to break it” approach)?! Well… yeah. Duh. Humans are human. No one is shocked.
(And people will, if asked, couch these preferences in claims about “bad discourse in plausibly deniable ways”, etc.? Again: duh.)
And I must point out that for all your complaints about strawmanning, you don’t seem to hesitate in doing that very thing to me. In your reply, you write as if I hadn’t included the parenthetical, where I clarify that of course I can understand the mindset in question, if I allow certain unflattering hypotheses into the space of possibilities. You might perhaps imagine reasons why I would be initially reluctant to do this. But that’s only initially. To put it another way, I have a prior against such hypotheses, but it’s not an insuperable one.
So, yes, I understand just fine; I am quite capable of “modeling the preferences” of such people as you mention. No doubt you will reply: “no, actually you don’t, and you aren’t”. But let’s flesh out this argument, proactively. Here’s how it would go, as far as I can tell:
“You are ascribing, to individuals who are clearly honest people of high integrity and strength of character, preferences and motivations which are indicative of the opposite of those traits. Therefore, your characterization cannot be accurate.”
“One man’s modus ponens is another man’s modus tollens. The behavior of the people in question points unambiguously at their possessing the ascribed preferences and motivations (which are hardly improbable a priori, and must be actively fought against even by the best of us, not simply assumed not to be operative). Therefore, perhaps they are not quite so honest, their integrity not so high, and their strength of character not so great.”
I don’t know what exactly you’d then say in response to this—presumably you won’t be convinced, especially since you included yourself in the given set of people. And, to be clear, I don’t think that disagreeing with this argument is evidence of anything; I am certainly not saying anything like “aha, and if you reject this argument that says that you are bad, then that just proves that you are bad!”.
I outline this reasoning only to provide a countervailing model, in response your own argument that I am simply clueless, that I have some sort of inability to understand why people do things and what they want, etc. No, I certainly do have a model of what’s going on here, and it predicts precisely what we in fact observe. You can argue that my model is wrong and yours is right, but that’s what you’ll have to argue—“you lack a model that describes and predicts reality” is an argument that’s available to you in this case.
Indeed, the most foundational essay for the moderation guidelines on this site, mentions this directly
One of these days, I will probably need to write an essay, which will be titled “‘Well-Kept Gardens Die By Pacifism’ Considered Harmful”. That day will not be today, but here’s a small down payment on that future essay:
When I read that essay, I found it pretty convincing. I didn’t see the problems, the mistakes—because I’d never been a moderator myself, and I’d never run a website.
That has changed now. And now that I have had my own experience of running an online forum (for five years now)—having decisions to make about moderation, having to deal with spam and egregious trolls and subtle trolls and just bad posters and crazy people and all sorts of things—now that I’ve actually had to face, and solve, the problems that Eliezer describes…
… now I can see how dreadfully, terribly wrong that essay is.
(Maybe the problem is that “Well-Kept Gardens Die By Pacifism” was written before Eliezer really started thinking about incentives? Maybe his own frustration with low-quality commenters on Overcoming Bias led him to drastically over-correct when trying to establish principles and norms for the then-new Less Wrong? Maybe he forgot to apply his own advice to his thinking about forum moderation? I don’t know, and a longer and deeper exploration of these musings will have to wait until I write the full version of this post.)
Stiil, I don’t want to give the impression that the essay is completely wrong. Eliezer writes:
I have seen rationalist communities die because they trusted their moderators too little.
But that was not a karma system, actually.
Here—you must trust yourselves.
A certain quote seems appropriate here: “Don’t believe in yourself! Believe that I believe in you!”
Because I really do honestly think that if you want to downvote a comment that seems low-quality… and yet you hesitate, wondering if maybe you’re downvoting just because you disagree with the conclusion or dislike the author… feeling nervous that someone watching you might accuse you of groupthink or echo-chamber-ism or (gasp!) censorship… then nine times of ten, I bet, nine times out of ten at least, it is a comment that really is low-quality.
Downvoting. He’s talking about downvoting. Not banning! That was a mistake this essay could have included, but didn’t. (Perhaps because Eliezer hadn’t thought of it yet? But I do generally default to thinking well of people whose writings I esteem highly, so that is not my first hypothesis.)
And while the karma system has its own problems (of which I have spoken, a few times), nevertheless it’s a heck of a lot better than letting authors ban whoever they want from their posts.
The fact that it’s nevertheless (apparently) not enough—that the combination of downvotes for the bad-but-not-overtly-bannable, and bans for the overly-bannable, is not enough for some authors—this is not some immutable fact of life. It simply speaks poorly of those authors.
Anyhow:
Well-kept gardens do not tend to die by accepting obviously norm-violating content.
Of course they do. That’s exactly how they tend to die. It’s precisely the obviously norm-violating content that is the problem, because if you accept that, then your members learn that your moderators either have an egregious inability to tell the good stuff from the bad, or that your moderators simply don’t care. That is deadly. That is when people simply stop trying to be good themselves—and your garden dies.
And there’s also another way in which well-kept gardens tend to die: when the moderators work to prevent the members from maintaining the garden; when “grass-roots” maintenance efforts—done, most commonly, simply with words—are punished, while the offenders are not punished. That is when those members who contribute the most to the garden’s sanctity—those who put in effort to rebut bad arguments, for instance, or otherwise to enforce norms and practices of good discussion and good thinking—will become disgusted with what they perceive as the moderators betraying the garden to its enemies.
[I will move this into meta in a few days, but this seemed important enough to have around on the frontpage for a bit]
Here is a short post with some of the moderation changes we are implementing. Ray, Ben and me are working on some more posts explaining some of our deeper reasoning, so this is just a list with some quick updates.
Even before the start of the open beta, I intended to allow trusted users to moderate their personal pages. The reasoning I outlined in our initial announcement post was as follows:
“We want to give trusted authors moderation powers for the discussions on their own posts, allowing them to foster their own discussion norms, and giving them their own sphere of influence on the discussion platform. We hope this will both make the lives of our top authors better and will also create a form of competition between different cultures and moderation paradigms on Lesswrong.”
And I also gave some further perspectives on this in my “Models of Moderation” post that I posted a week ago.
We now finally got around to implement the technology for this. But the big question that has been on my mind while working on the implementation has been:
Me, Ray, Ben and Vaniver talked for quite a while about the pros and cons, and considered a bunch of perspectives, but the two major considerations on our mind were:
After a good amount of internal discussion, as well as feedback from some of the top content contributors on LW (including Eliezer), we settled on allowing users above 2000 karma to moderate their own frontpage posts, and allow users above 100 karma to moderate their personal blogs. This strikes me as the best compromise between the different considerations we had.
Here are the details about the implementation:
I also want to allow users to create private comments on posts, that are only visible to themselves and the author of the post, and allow authors to make comments private (as an alternative to deleting them). But that will have to wait until we get around to implementing it.
We tested this reasonably thoroughly, but there is definitely a chance we missed something, so let us know if you notice any weird behavior around commenting on posts, or using the moderation tools, and we will fix it ASAP.