If terminal lucidity is a real phenomenon, information lost to dementia could still be recoverable in principle. So, cryo-preserving people suffering from dementia for later mind uploading could still work sometimes.
I just heard about terminal lucidity for the first time from Janus:
If your loved one is suffering from (even late-stage) dementia, it's likely that the information of their mind isn't lost, just inaccessible until a cure is found.
Sign them up for cryonics.
This seems pretty important if true. I'd previously thought that if a loved one came down with Alzheimer's, that was likely the end for them in this branch of the world[1], even with cryonics. I'd planned to set up some form of assisted suicide for myself if I was ever diagnosed, to get frozen before my brain got damaged too much.
Skimming the Wikipedia article and the first page of Google results, the documentation we have of terminal lucidity doesn’t seem great. But it tentatively looks to me like it’s probably a real thing at least in some form? Though I guess with the relative rarity of clearly documented cases, it might actually only work for some specific neurological disorders. I find it somewhat hard to imagine how something like this could work with a case of severe Alzheimer's. Doesn't that literally atrophy your brain?
This is very much not my wheelhouse though. I'd appreciate other people's opinions, especially if they know something about this area of research.
It seems maybe possible in physical principle to bring back even minds lost to thermodynamic chaos. But that seems like an engineering undertaking so utterly massive I'm not sure even a mature civilisation controlling most of the lightcone could pull it off.
I'd guess that you can suffer quite severe impairment from only a small amount of physical brain damage if the damage occurs in locations important for connecting different brain areas/capabilities. Information being "not lost, just inaccessible" seems realistic to me. However, I wouldn't base this intuition on cases of terminal lucidity.
3Lucius Bushnaq
Thank you. Do you know anyone who claims to have observed it?
Nobody I personally know, no. I can't think of anyone in my professional sphere who has even mentioned it as a possibility, but on the flip side, I haven't gone around asking. More generally speaking, periods of increased lucidity are a thing in patients with dementia. There are some forms, not so much in Alzheimer's, where this is a diagnostic hallmark. As disease progresses, they become fewer and far between, and I would hasten a guess that eventually they vanish altogether.
This now makes me think of the possibility that elderly dementia patients m... (read more)