Notwithstanding that Grok is often recruited in a charged or condescending way to win arguments, I think it's a pretty good feature:
It requires no effort to invoke an LLM with the context of the tweet thread.
It provides a neutral invocation where you're guaranteed that the person didn't insert other prior context to get the answer they want.
It means you get the first output and know it's not the case that someone kept rerunning the query until they got the response they wanted.
In short, you get convenience and a neutral fact checker. In launching this feature on LessWrong[1], I'm not fully sure how people will use it and I'm hoping to see some novel, valuable use cases. Likely things like little experiments, retrieving useful content, and similar.
Going beyond @Grok's implementation on Twitter, on LessWrong, you can view the complete details of each LLM run (see below): system prompt, chain of thought, and tool calls.
What about the noise of having LLM content showing up? I'll be keeping a close eye on how it goes. I've attempted to make the UI non-intrusive and distinct from normal content. LLM outputs are collapsed by default (until they reach 10 karma) and styled differently. There are rate limits on how many times someone can @<model>. Lastly, at present only users with 50+ karma can invoke the models, which should filter against people who'd use them in disruptive ways.
The LLM Run page:
Happy invocations! Feel free to try it out on this post!
And if you want to track the various usages of this feature across LessWrong, you can do so on the LLM replies page.
A karma score of 50+ is required to use it during beta.
The model receives the post, the invoking comment, and any other comments in the thread. The model is able to search both the web and LessWrong content.
A broad but non-exhaustive list of model options will be included. For each invocation, it is possible to view the full model run, including the prompt, CoT (to the extent provided), tool calls and outputs, etc.
There are many very adversarial issues that get discussed on LessWrong, and I expect being able to ask an LLM for input to help substantially.
Why do you expect this? I don’t think of LLM output as being particularly neutral, or of their summaries as being particularly accurate. Among other things, they seem to have a prior where any take on a subject ought to be given equal weight/salience, are sensitive to framing (in a way that does not seem to me fully fixed by prompt visibility), and afaict are subject to a slew of other distortive biases. They do not have LW cultural norms. When I play forward what happens if LLMs are asked to weigh in on adversarial issues, I mostly imagine having to wade through verbose text which puts the relevance in the wrong place, is subtly misleading, sometimes just wrong, and ultimately not worth reading. Perhaps the entire disagreement is that I do expect LLMs to reliably produce below average content, especially relative to the people on this website (which is the reason I come to this website). But maybe there is a use case I am failing to see here.
Or if you prefer, "@Claude", "@Opus", "@Astra"
@Grok is a popular Twitter/X feature where if you tag Grok in a tweet, Grok will respond in a comment. The stereotypical use case is "@Grok is this true?" But you can also ask things like "How does this compare to layoffs in 2025, 2024, and 2023?" and "How would you verify AI in the domain of AI research?"
Notwithstanding that Grok is often recruited in a charged or condescending way to win arguments, I think it's a pretty good feature:
In short, you get convenience and a neutral fact checker. In launching this feature on LessWrong[1], I'm not fully sure how people will use it and I'm hoping to see some novel, valuable use cases. Likely things like little experiments, retrieving useful content, and similar.
Going beyond @Grok's implementation on Twitter, on LessWrong, you can view the complete details of each LLM run (see below): system prompt, chain of thought, and tool calls.
What about the noise of having LLM content showing up? I'll be keeping a close eye on how it goes. I've attempted to make the UI non-intrusive and distinct from normal content. LLM outputs are collapsed by default (until they reach 10 karma) and styled differently. There are rate limits on how many times someone can @<model>. Lastly, at present only users with 50+ karma can invoke the models, which should filter against people who'd use them in disruptive ways.
The LLM Run page:
Happy invocations! Feel free to try it out on this post!
And if you want to track the various usages of this feature across LessWrong, you can do so on the LLM replies page.