Made an opinionated "update" for the anti-kibitzer mode script; it works for current LessWrong with its agree/disagree votes and all that jazz, fixes some longstanding bugs that break the formatting of the site and allow you to see votes in certain places, and doesn't indent usernames anymore. Install Tampermonkey and browse to this link if you'd like to use it.
Semi-related, I am instituting a Reign Of Terror policy for my poasts/shortform, which I will update my moderation policy with. The general goal of these policies is to reduce the amount of time I spend thinking and distressing about the same shit every social media platform makes you stress out about to the detriment of your mental health: which person is commenting on my posts, what upboats are they/I getting, Muh Status, etc. I respect that these are stringent enough requirements, that I have epsilon negotiating leverage, and that I will probably end up either banning or scaring off nine of the ten people that would have ever commented on or read the things I plan to write on LW. This is the only way I think I'll be able to tolerate writing anything for smart people moving forward, so I'm going to do it even if nobody ever comments on my posts again.
The Reign of Terror policy says:
This only applies to posts and shortforms I make from-now-on. I certainly haven't followed it myself. You of course get one opportunity to follow the reign of terror policy and then I will click the ban forever button, because even if you've been a diligent sport throughout the last 800 posts, I won't know who you are when you decide to mention in passing that you used to work at Google or MIRI or whatever.
I was reacting more to the very detailed rules that don't (to me) match my intuitions of good commenting on LW, and the declaration of perma-bans with fairly small provocation. A lot will depend on implementation - how many comments lc allows, and how many commenters get banned.
There's practically no reason on a rationality forum for you to assert your identity or personal status over another commenter. I agree the rules I've given are very detailed. I don't agree that any of the vast majority of valuable comments on LessWrong are somehow bannable by m... (read more)