Day 2 of forced writing with an accountability partner
With all of the existential weight of the alignment problem upon people’s shoulders, some may find it in poor taste to discuss gimmicky ways of solving it. I am not one of those people, so in this shortform I’ll introduce what I call “Top God Alignment,” which is perhaps most oversimplistically summarized as “the simulation argument + pascal’s wager + wishful chicanery.”
Up front, do I think it will work? No. However, I’m currently unclear why it won’t work, and after asking multiple people and hearing unconvincing objections (some of which the people retracted in the face of responses), I’m increasingly curious to figure out where this is wrong.
What is the method? It is roughly formulated as follows:
The result is seemingly a recursive structure which, theoretically, could result in dozens or hundreds (or more) simulated worlds. Thus, “Bob” cannot tell whether he is in fact “Top God,” or if he is just another Bob’s Charlie (i.e., a demi-god). Out of fear of being brutally punished, Bob will ideally prefer to go along with the cycle.
In a future post, I will go into detail to respond to the objections that I have heard from people and/or I suspect some people will have. Then again, it seems entirely plausible that by that time, I will have actually written enough about this idea to discover some clear flaw that just isn’t that obvious in conversations, where the premises and arguments are a bit fast and loose. Still, I’ll highlight now that I think that if you assign credence to the simulation argument and understand its defenses, this does a fair bit prebuttal. Moreover, I think people are too often hastily dismissive of Pascal’s Wager on the basis of relatively slim (but still potentially legitimate!) objections, such as the Professor’s God.
Despite my responses, I’m still incredibly pessimistic and don’t take this seriously. There are a few reasons for this:
Ultimately, as of right now, this seems to be the best option in my mental folder of “gimmick alignment solutions,” which is an incredibly low bar. But if nothing else I’ve had fun playing with it and semi-sarcastically presenting it at parties/with friends. Now that I've established myself as Top God's Prophet Premier, I'll sign off 🙏
I have a response to this—check back tomorrow!