[ Question ]

What's the best approach to curating a newsfeed to maximize useful contrasting POV?

by bgold 1 min read26th Apr 20193 comments


In Superforecasters, Tetlock describes one superforecaster as having built a collection of automated scripts and sources to get useful information from a variety of different sources and different perspectives. This seems very useful and I'd like to emulate it.

I'm looking for a generalizable approach where, given a specific topic (ex. AI) I can curate sources (ex. Twitter accounts) that maximizes diversity of points (ex. different perspectives on AI Alignment risk). I'd like to avoid the bias where I only use sources that are well known and popular, which seems particularly likely to happen in cases where I am not familiar with the field

I have a few different tactics in mind, but I haven't yet settled on a cohesive strategy, and am interested in suggestions, in particular if you've done this before.

New Answer
Ask Related Question
New Comment
Write here. Select text for formatting options.
We support LaTeX: Cmd-4 for inline, Cmd-M for block-level (Ctrl on Windows).
You can switch between rich text and markdown in your user settings.

1 Answers

I remember there being a bunch of websites dedicated to doing this, though I am not using any of them. AllSides is I think the example that I have been referred to most often.

Speaking about things that I do often do:

  • On Wikipedia articles I often read the talk pages in order to get a sense of what viewpoints I might be missing by just reading the article
  • In terms of general diversity of view perspective, I think the following ordering in terms of media sources roughly holds (starting with the most diverse):
    • Online Forums/Reddit/LessWrong (mostly because healthy comment sections tend to cover a lot of ideological ground)
    • Facebook discussions among my friends
    • Textbooks (there is a particular genre of handbook-like/overview-based textbooks that tend to do a good job of summarizing many viewpoints in a field)
    • Private online blogs
    • Educational Youtube channels
    • News articles
  • For politics and culture-war related stuff, there is r/theMotte, which I have heard has an exceptional amount of viewpoint diversity compared to most other forums
  • I know that some people successfully use Twitter for this, but I don't use Twitter, so no idea
  • In AI Alignment we luckily have the AI Alignment Newsletter, which seems to cover a lot of the things happening around AI-Alignment