Epistemic status: possibly very evil devil's advocacy, philospohicly unsophisticard ruminations
We are all familiar with Singer's drowning child thought experiment. I have often found it very compelling, or at least felt I ought to find it very compelling. My revealed preferences, as with those of nearly everyone else, tell a different story.
But it has always struck me that Singer's story can be read in two directions, and social desirability bias would likely prevent one from reading it aloud in the less-common way.
If a thought experiment is to drastically alter one's life, it seems worth a little devil's advocacy.
In this spirit, I ask if the fact that one does not donate all their energy to ameliorating the plight of the world's most impoverished provide some evidence that one does not, in fact, care as much about the near-by drowning child as they think they do?
What are some purely-selfish reasons one might have for saving the child. I can think of a few.
You gain some prestige as a hero.
You demonstrate your strength and competence publicly in the event someone witnesses your heroism.
It is fun to imagine heroic acts in your head that you would not, in fact, do in real life.
The gratefulness of the child and/or their parents isn't without value.
Saving a child in this way is a novel, interesting experience.
If we alter Singer's story such that a hero-for-hire offers to save the near-by child, and he asks for a sum equivalent to the price of your suit (and a guarantee of that you will keep the transaction confidential) we can remove the weight of these motivations. Supposing you cannot swim and the hero-for-hire is the only person around, would you take this deal?
I think I would take the deal, but if I'm honest with myself it does seem very slightly less compelling.
If we extend this scenario and imagine that accepting this deal every week would mean sacrificing half your annual salary, the decision becomes even more complex. Would the majority still take the deal? Or would they perhaps find a path to their office where large bodies of water are not in view?
Singer also omits the "friend enemy distinction". Generally we treat all children as friends rather than enemies, but what if that child had killed your sister?
What if it's baby Hitler?
Etc.
Singer's parable is in fact drawn from the Mohists of ancient China. But another ancient Chinese proverb says something about "teaching a man to fish".
If a parent keeps losing kids to drowning, is it really your job to save them every time? Might it be that parents' / rescue teams' responsibility? What difference does it make when we diffuse responsibility to the whole society rather than have it concretely placed in certain individuals who we hold accountable ahead of time?
Epistemic status: possibly very evil devil's advocacy, philospohicly unsophisticard ruminations
We are all familiar with Singer's drowning child thought experiment. I have often found it very compelling, or at least felt I ought to find it very compelling. My revealed preferences, as with those of nearly everyone else, tell a different story.
But it has always struck me that Singer's story can be read in two directions, and social desirability bias would likely prevent one from reading it aloud in the less-common way.
If a thought experiment is to drastically alter one's life, it seems worth a little devil's advocacy.
In this spirit, I ask if the fact that one does not donate all their energy to ameliorating the plight of the world's most impoverished provide some evidence that one does not, in fact, care as much about the near-by drowning child as they think they do?
What are some purely-selfish reasons one might have for saving the child. I can think of a few.
If we alter Singer's story such that a hero-for-hire offers to save the near-by child, and he asks for a sum equivalent to the price of your suit (and a guarantee of that you will keep the transaction confidential) we can remove the weight of these motivations. Supposing you cannot swim and the hero-for-hire is the only person around, would you take this deal?
I think I would take the deal, but if I'm honest with myself it does seem very slightly less compelling.
If we extend this scenario and imagine that accepting this deal every week would mean sacrificing half your annual salary, the decision becomes even more complex. Would the majority still take the deal? Or would they perhaps find a path to their office where large bodies of water are not in view?