I think we disagree primarily on 2 (and also how doomy the default case is, but let's set that aside).
In claiming that rationality is as real as reproductive fitness, I'm claiming that there's a theory of evolution out there.
I think that's a crux between you and me. I'm no longer sure if it's a crux between you and Richard. (ETA: I shouldn't call this a crux, I wouldn't change my mind on whether MIRI work is on-the-margin more valuable if I changed my mind on this, but it would be a pretty significant update.)
Reproductive fitness does seem to me like the kind of abstraction you can build on, though. For example, the theory of kin selection is a significant theory built on top of it.
Yeah, I was ignoring that sort of stuff. I do think this post would be better without the evolutionary fitness example because of this confusion. I was imagining the "unreal rationality" world to be similar to what Daniel mentions below:
I think I was imagining an alternative world where useful theories of rationality could only be about as precise as theories of liberalism, or current theories about why England had an industrial revolution when it did, and no other country did instead.
But, separately, I don't get how you're seeing reproductive fitness and evolution as having radically different realness, such that you wanted to systematically correct. I agree they're separate questions, but in fact I see the realness of reproductive fitness as largely a matter of the realness of evolution -- without the overarching theory, reproductive fitness functions would be a kind of irrelevant abstraction and therefore less real.
Yeah, I'm going to try to give a different explanation that doesn't involve "realness".
When groups of humans try to build complicated stuff, they tend to do so using abstraction. The most complicated stuff is built on a tower of many abstractions, each sitting on top of lower-level abstractions. This is most evident (to me) in software development, where the abstraction hierarchy is staggeringly large, but it applies elsewhere, too: the low-level abstractions of mechanical engineering are "levers", "gears", "nails", etc.
A pretty key requirement for abstractions to work is that they need to be as non-leaky as possible, so that you do not have to think about them as much. When I code in Python and I write "x + y", I can assume that the result will be the sum of the two values, and this is basically always right. Notably, I don't have to think about the machine code that deals with the fact that overflow might happen. When I write in C, I do have to think about overflow, but I don't have to think about how to implement addition at the bitwise level. This becomes even more important at the group level, because communication is expensive, slow, and low-bandwidth relative to thought, and so you need non-leaky abstractions so that you don't need to communicate all the caveats and intuitions that would accompany a leaky abstraction.
One way to operationalize this is that to be built on, an abstraction must give extremely precise (and accurate) predictions.
It's fine if there's some complicated input to the abstraction, as long as that input can be estimated well in practice. This is what I imagine is going on with evolution and reproductive fitness -- if you can estimate reproductive fitness, then you can get very precise and accurate predictions, as with e.g. the Price equation that Daniel mentioned. (And you can estimate fitness, either by using things like the Price equation + real data, or by controlling the environment where you set up the conditions that make something reproductively fit.)
If a thing cannot provide extremely precise and accurate predictions, then I claim that humans mostly can't build on top of it. We can use it to make intuitive arguments about things very directly related to it, but can't generalize it to something more far-off. Some examples from these comment threads of what "inferences about directly related things" looks like:
current theories about why England had an industrial revolution when it did
[biology] has far more practical consequences (thinking of medicine)
understanding why overuse of antibiotics might weaken the effect of antibiotics [based on knowledge of evolution]
Note that in all of these examples, you can more or less explain the conclusion in terms of the thing it depends on. E.g. You can say "overuse of antibiotics might weaken the effect of antibiotics because the bacteria will evolve / be selected to be resistant to the antibiotic".
In contrast, for abstractions like "logic gates", "assembly language", "levers", etc, we have built things like rockets and search engines that certainly could not have been built without those abstractions, but nonetheless you'd be hard pressed to explain e.g. how a search engine works if you were only allowed to talk with abstractions at the level of logic gates. This is because the precision afforded by those abstractions allows us to build huge hierarchies of better abstractions.
So now I'd go back and state our crux as:
Is there a theory of rationality that is sufficiently precise to build hierarchies of abstraction?
I would guess not. It sounds like you would guess yes.
I think this is upstream of 2. When I say I somewhat agree with 2, I mean that you can probably get a theory of rationality that makes imprecise predictions, which allows you to say things about "directly relevant things", which will probably let you say some interesting things about AI systems, just not very much. I'd expect that, to really affect ML systems, given how far away from regular ML research MIRI research is, you would need a theory that's precise enough to build hierarchies with.
(I think I'd also expect that you need to directly use the results of the research to build an AI system, rather than using it to inform existing efforts to build AI.)
(You might wonder why I'm optimistic about conceptual ML safety work, which is also not precise enough to build hierarchies of abstraction. The basic reason is that ML safety is "directly relevant" to existing ML systems, and so you don't need to build hierarchies of abstraction -- just the first imprecise layer is plausibly enough. You can see this in the fact that there are already imprecise concepts that are directly talking about safety.)
The security mindset model of reaching high confidence is not that you have a model whose overall predictive accuracy is high enough, but rather that you have an argument for security which depends on few assumptions, each of which is individually very likely. E.G., in computer security you don't usually need exact models of attackers, and a system which relies on those is less likely to be secure.
Your few assumptions need to talk about the system you actually build. On the model I'm outlining, it's hard to state the assumptions for the system you actually build, and near-impossible to be very confident in those assumptions, because they are (at least) one level of hierarchy higher than the (assumed imprecise) theory of rationality.
Epistemic status: trying to vaguely gesture at vague intuitions. A similar idea was explored here under the heading "the intelligibility of intelligence", although I hadn't seen it before writing this post. As of 2020, I consider this follow-up comment to be a better summary of the thing I was trying to convey with this post than the post itself. The core disagreement is about how much we expect the limiting case of arbitrarily high intelligence to tell us about the AGIs whose behaviour we're worried about.
There’s a mindset which is common in the rationalist community, which I call “realism about rationality” (the name being intended as a parallel to moral realism). I feel like my skepticism about agent foundations research is closely tied to my skepticism about this mindset, and so in this essay I try to articulate what it is.
Humans ascribe properties to entities in the world in order to describe and predict them. Here are three such properties: "momentum", "evolutionary fitness", and "intelligence". These are all pretty useful properties for high-level reasoning in the fields of physics, biology and AI, respectively. There's a key difference between the first two, though. Momentum is very amenable to formalisation: we can describe it using precise equations, and even prove things about it. Evolutionary fitness is the opposite: although nothing in biology makes sense without it, no biologist can take an organism and write down a simple equation to define its fitness in terms of more basic traits. This isn't just because biologists haven't figured out that equation yet. Rather, we have excellent reasons to think that fitness is an incredibly complicated "function" which basically requires you to describe that organism's entire phenotype, genotype and environment.
In a nutshell, then, realism about rationality is a mindset in which reasoning and intelligence are more like momentum than like fitness. It's a mindset which makes the following ideas seem natural:
To be clear, I am neither claiming that realism about rationality makes people dogmatic about such ideas, nor claiming that they're all false. In fact, from a historical point of view I’m quite optimistic about using maths to describe things in general. But starting from that historical baseline, I’m inclined to adjust downwards on questions related to formalising intelligent thought, whereas rationality realism would endorse adjusting upwards. This essay is primarily intended to explain my position, not justify it, but one important consideration for me is that intelligence as implemented in humans and animals is very messy, and so are our concepts and inferences, and so is the closest replica we have so far (intelligence in neural networks). It's true that "messy" human intelligence is able to generalise to a wide variety of domains it hadn't evolved to deal with, which supports rationality realism, but analogously an animal can be evolutionarily fit in novel environments without implying that fitness is easily formalisable.
Another way of pointing at rationality realism: suppose we model humans as internally-consistent agents with beliefs and goals. This model is obviously flawed, but also predictively powerful on the level of our everyday lives. When we use this model to extrapolate much further (e.g. imagining a much smarter agent with the same beliefs and goals), or base morality on this model (e.g. preference utilitarianism, CEV), is that more like using Newtonian physics to approximate relativity (works well, breaks down in edge cases) or more like cavemen using their physics intuitions to reason about space (a fundamentally flawed approach)?
Another gesture towards the thing: a popular metaphor for Kahneman and Tversky's dual process theory is a rider trying to control an elephant. Implicit in this metaphor is the localisation of personal identity primarily in the system 2 rider. Imagine reversing that, so that the experience and behaviour you identify with are primarily driven by your system 1, with a system 2 that is mostly a Hansonian rationalisation engine on top (one which occasionally also does useful maths). Does this shift your intuitions about the ideas above, e.g. by making your CEV feel less well-defined? I claim that the latter perspective is just as sensible as the former, and perhaps even more so - see, for example, Paul Christiano's model of the mind, which leads him to conclude that "imagining conscious deliberation as fundamental, rather than a product and input to reflexes that actually drive behavior, seems likely to cause confusion."
These ideas have been stewing in my mind for a while, but the immediate trigger for this post was a conversation about morality which went along these lines:
I had a lot of difficulty in figuring out what I actually meant during that conversation, but I think a quick way to summarise the disagreement is that O is a rationality realist, and I’m not. This is not a problem, per se: I'm happy that some people are already working on AI safety from this mindset, and I can imagine becoming convinced that rationality realism is a more correct mindset than my own. But I think it's a distinction worth keeping in mind, because assumptions baked into underlying worldviews are often difficult to notice, and also because the rationality community has selection effects favouring this particular worldview even though it doesn't necessarily follow from the community's founding thesis (that humans can and should be more rational).