This is a special post for quick takes by Screwtape. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
"You claimed Bella says the world is flat. But it's not true that Bella said that. Last week, she made a speech where she said the world is round. Look, the video of that speech is right at this url, here's the timestamp."
Speaking very loosely, there's three possible worlds. There's World 1, where Bella consistently says the world is flat. There's World 2, where Bella consistently says the world is round. And there's World 3, where Bella sometimes says the world is flat and sometimes says its round. If you have a video of Bella saying the world is round, then (barring AI deepfakes or the like) you've ruled out World 1. You haven't distinguished yet between World 2 and World 3.
Bella might have changed her mind between the intervening points! Bella might have accidentally misspoken! Also, it is basically impossible to prove a negative, so it's always possible Bella said something else in some private conversation somewhere. But Bella also might be straightforwardly saying false things.
(No subtweet habit, I read the MAPLE response bit: "Has Soryu said that he is the only trustworthy person? This is the opposite of the truth. He regularly praises other teachers..." I am not here trying to make a claim of whether Soryu is trustworthy or not here, I just have an acquired mental tic about this move.)