3101

LESSWRONG
LW

3100
Personal Blog

1

Reality versus Human Expectations

by Theist
20th Mar 2018
1 min read
8

1

Personal Blog

1

Reality versus Human Expectations
4Richard_Kennaway
1Theist
2Richard_Kennaway
1Theist
2Richard_Kennaway
1Theist
2AABoyles
1Theist
New Comment
8 comments, sorted by
top scoring
Click to highlight new comments since: Today at 1:46 PM
[-]Richard_Kennaway7y40

3. Alter reality so it more closely aligns with human desires.

4. Alter humans so their desires more closely align with reality.

1a-4a: Replace "humans" by "oneself".

1b-4b: Replace "humans" by "the people you deal with from day to day".

Reply
[-]Theist7y10

So of the expanded options, which would you choose?

Reply
[-]Richard_Kennaway7y20

3, 3a, and 3b.

Reply
[-]Theist7y10

In that case, how do you handle the problem of humans wanting the "wrong" things? (Meaning people wanting things that ultimately result in bad outcomes for themselves or others.)

Would altering reality so it more closely aligns with the humans' desires include avoiding negative consequences, side effects, and externalities?

Reply
[-]Richard_Kennaway7y20

You can always come up with exceptions to general rules. Yes, these issues would have to be handled. How they might be handled is not something that strikes me as useful to talk about in the present context, which is concerned with very general and abstract scenarios, and which, in general, are preferable to which others.

Generally speaking, I agree with Swift's likening of avoiding suffering by cutting off one's desires to cutting off one's feet because one lacks shoes.

Reply
[-]Theist7y10

The Stoical scheme of supplying our wants by lopping off our desires, is like cutting off our feet when we want shoes.

Lovely quote, thank you.

Reply
[-]AABoyles7y20

Definitely 2. If you start messing with reality, things get really boring really quickly.

Reply
[-]Theist7y10

I think that's my choice as well. Humans expectations are much narrower than reality appears to be. If reality conformed to human expectation then no one would ever be surprised, which I think would be sad.

Reply
Moderation Log
More from Theist
View more
Curated and popular this week
8Comments

Given two options:

1. Alter reality so it more closely aligns with human expectations.

2. Alter humans so their expectations more closely align with reality.

If it cost the same to implement either option, which would you prefer and why?