LESSWRONG
LW

307
hamnox
1295383460
Message
Dialogue
Subscribe

Hiding in a shrubbery

Posts

Sorted by New

Wikitag Contributions

Comments

Sorted by
Newest
No wikitag contributions to display.
5hamnox's Shortform
6y
22
AI Induced Psychosis: A shallow investigation
hamnox2d20

Wait wait hold on a moment.

This is far from the most important thing to discuss about your post, but I have to say it. Your project's git repo has a list of archived characters, with no explanation for why they were passed over—I'm interested in knowing the reasoning for why they each weren't picked, but my lack of insight there is not why I'm posting now.

I want to talk about how there's one named Tim, who's psychotically convinced he's an AI alignment genius.

Had to put my phone down for a moment to process this level of irony. I don't have to ask why you didn't use that one—I can think of several reasons—but why even make it? How dare you be so funny in a github repo, where I least expected it?

Reply1
[Fiction] [Comic] Effective Altruism and Rationality meet at a Secular Solstice afterparty
hamnox3d40

It's quite a conversation. Deep topics, but touched with a lightness as two similar but different people feel each other out.

The art too. /chefs kiss🤌/. There's something beautiful about the subtle lineart of interaction behind the text, the cup passing hands and their true-to-character sitting postures. I didn't notice it consciously on the first read through, just felt its seamless effect. Brilliant how it all slowly goes dark, til the sun rises in the end—mirroring the solstice I imagine they met to celebrate.

Reply
[Fiction] [Comic] Effective Altruism and Rationality meet at a Secular Solstice afterparty
hamnox3d40

The premise intrigued me. That was lovely to read. I'm glad I did.

It feels like this exposed something important, a crux that always lived in my head and relationships, but in such a way that stays deeply integrated. If that makes any sense. No part of it stood out as a quotable or author tract; I stayed in emotional connection rather than jumping out and up a meta level to intellectualize. I want to share this.

Reply
Winning the power to lose
hamnox3mo60

In disagreements where both sides want the same outcome, and disagree on what’s going to happen, then either side might win a tussle over the steering wheel, but all must win or lose the real game together. The real game is played against reality.

Winning the fight for control over the steering wheel is a very powerful visual metaphor, I'm glad to have it in my arsenal now. Thank you for writing this.

Reply
My "2.9 trauma limit"
hamnox2y60

It generally had to do with me trying to navigate a part of me that really wanted to just have a nice village, and be a humble village priest who helped their local community be nice. And a part of me that felt "man, the village is not safe. I can't in good conscious just stay here having a nice life. The spirit of the village compels me to leave the village and figure out how to help protect the village. But man something about that feels really sad/bad."

OOF.

Had a similar realization recently. It sucks. I was really lucky¹ to have access to competent emotional support when I did.

¹ not in fact luck, but skilled organizers who were prepared-in-advance for an increased likelihood of such events AT their event.

Reply1
Follow up to medical miracle
hamnox3y90

"an easy lever might be a guide to obvious failure modes of supplements and medications"

I desire to see more things like this.. Especially if they're presented not as a list of "gotchas", but as specifics of a general moving-parts model of how naive models/strategies operate in a complex space. Should be lots of base rates being thrown around.

A system for recognizing when things are helping and hurting, and phasing treatments out if they don’t justify the mental load

This part has been a historical blocker to me using luck/exploration based medicine. If one is dissociated, alexythmic, or has an experience completely dominated by one sensation like pain or anxiety, then it's going to be pretty hard to notice fine gradations in how well they're doing. Not having precision really narrows the possible paths to success; effect has to be almost overdetermined before one actually updates on the evidence.

An extension of the noticeable risks and helping/hurting points I think is worth separating out: how to identify and avoid literal poisons. Not risky bets, per se, but things that are likely to directly harm the objective (health) and the other conditions necessary to make your strategy viable (kill your liver, mind, ability to move under your own power).I think it's a useful comparison point to know what it takes to figure out what is safe to eat in an unfamiliar environment. There's a protocol for slow steps of Graduated exposure and Waiting to see how well it's tolerated. Accumulated culture and the FDA are so very cheating technique. It's worth understanding how much work it otherwise takes to narrow down what world you are in without leaning on them.

Reply
(My understanding of) What Everyone in Technical Alignment is Doing and Why
hamnox3y21

I wanna offer feedback on the READING.

at "Off the cuff I’d give something like 10%, 3%, 1% for these respectively (conditioned on the previous premises) which multiplies to .003%", the verbal version doubled back to remind what the referents for each percentage we're, then read the sentence again.

that was PERFECT. high value add. made sure the actual point was gotten across, when it would have been very easy to just mentally tune out numerical information.

Reply
TEAM: a dramatically improved form of therapy
hamnox3y30

In TEAM, the therapist takes on a different role: instead of trying to convince the patient to change his or her thoughts, the therapist tries to find reasons that the patient should not change.

I recognize this model! The book "Immunity to Change" goes into great detail on a similar process.

Applying that specifically in a therapeutic context, to clear the path for treatment to really work, is SO BRIILLIANT!

Reply
MIRI announces new "Death With Dignity" strategy
hamnox3y70

scalable decentralized currency/contract/communication systems

Oh? Do say more

Reply
Load More
7Outline: The Rectifying of Maps
3y
0
15Faerie Rings
4y
2
19What I Learned From Running a Pol.is Conversation
5y
3
7 Agency Volume of "A Map That Reflects the Territory" Set - My Personal Commentary
5y
0
20Epistemology Volume of "A Map That Reflects the Territory" Set - My Personal Commentary
5y
1
5hamnox's Shortform
6y
22
13What would a zetetic explanation be for the rationality community?
Q
7y
Q
2
10First steps of a rationality skill bootstrap
7y
0
9Creating Space to Cultivate Skill
8y
8
8Learnday
8y
1
Load More