LESSWRONG
LW

Progress Studies
Frontpage

20

[ Question ]

Has a technological dependency graph been made?

by Mati_Roy
27th Feb 2020
1 min read
A
3
4

20

Progress Studies
Frontpage

20

Has a technological dependency graph been made?
6Douglas_Knight
6[anonymous]
2dumky
1Mati_Roy
New Answer
New Comment

3 Answers sorted by
top scoring

Douglas_Knight

Feb 28, 2020

60

That's a good idea, but a word of warning. History is based on such little data that it must be the product of circular reasoning. Most historical claims about what technologies existed are based on implicit beliefs about tech trees, while most beliefs about tech trees are based on explicit beliefs about what technologies existed. Yes, it is better to make the beliefs about tech trees explicit, although there is risk of ossifying these beliefs. Anyhow, I recommend that you widen your priors by reading Lucio Russo's book Forgotten Revolution about how much science and technology the ancient Greeks had.

Add Comment

Feb 28, 2020

60

Tongue half in cheek - play a game like Civilization? https://vignette.wikia.nocookie.net/civilization/images/e/eb/Tech_Tree_%28Civ6%29.jpg/revision/latest?cb=20170301234054

Add Comment

dumky

Mar 09, 2020

20

James Burke mentioned such a graph being worked on in a talk he gave in 2009. Not sure how it progressed. https://youtu.be/7G8YHWbi-9U

Note: if you’re interested in this topic, check out Burke’s book and TV show, Connections. It’s fascinating (a lot of clever repurposing and also happenstance).

Add Comment
[-]Mati_Roy5y10

Thanks!

this seems to be the project: https://k-web.org/ with this graph being the beta version: https://webbrain.com/brainpage/brain/C6015FA0-82BF-F1FA-9D05-0EA9FD7F845E#-2751

Reply
Rendering 0/1 comments, sorted by
top scoring
(show more)
Click to highlight new comments since: Today at 11:38 AM
Moderation Log
More from Mati_Roy
View more
Curated and popular this week
A
3
0

I would like to see a graph of technologies that were developed during humanity's history that shows which ones were (likely) necessary for the development of which other. It might provide useful insights.