Just said to someone that I would by default read anything they wrote to me in a positive light, and that if they wanted to be mean to me in text, they should put '(mean)' after the statement.
Then realized that, if I had to put '(mean)' after everything I wrote on the internet that I wanted to read as slightly abrupt or confrontational, I would definitely be abrupt and confrontational on the internet less.
I am somewhat more confrontational than I endorse, and having to actually say to myself and the world that I was intending to be harsh, rather than simply demonstrating it, would lead to me being harsh somewhat less often.
I do basically know when I'm being confrontational in public, and am Doing It On Purpose, and also expect others to know it, and almost never say "I wasn't being confrontational" when I was being confrontational, and somehow having to signal it more overtly than it is already (that is to say, very) signaled would encourage me to tone it down.
In person, I even sometimes say 'I am being difficult in a way that I endorse/feels correct/feels important' and just go on being difficult, and considering that I'm about to do that in advance doesn't discourage me from being difficult.
Might start running the internal simulation 'you have to put a '(mean)' tag on something when you're intending to be a little mean on the internet' to see how it changes things.
(I am not going to defend the position 'sometimes it is correct to be a little mean'; I'm more interested in the other phenomenon.)
Yes exactly; I'm curious about how many more opportunities for greater intentionality/reflective-endorsement might be lurking in other areas, where I just haven't created the right test/handle (but may believe that I've created the right one).
I'm also mindful of the opposite failure mode, though, where attempting to surface something to yourself internally actually causes you to over-index on it, leading to paralysis, where the thing was only present in very small doses and your threshold was poorly calibrated.