This is a special post for quick takes by Mo Putera. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
Fwiw I'm >9:1 confident that I'm Kenyan. I Don't Write Like ChatGPT. ChatGPT Writes Like Me is written with substantial AI assistance. It gets 100% on Pangram and the tone and rhythm just seems way too AI-like. Maybe you're like "oh doesn't that just prove his point? But no.
As some points of comparison, your comment doesn't read that way at all. Neither does his essays from 2021 and earlier. Maybe you're like, argumentative styles are different from his usual fare? But I asked Claude to come up with some Kenyan essays from that time period that has this ChatGPT rhythm and Claude was unable to[1]. If his argument was actually correct, you'd expect way more pre-2022 Kenyan writers to sound the way he describes.
EDIT: The biggest reason I could imagine being wrong (and I don't think this is likely), which is why I'm not at >>99:1, is if he intentionally wrote in an extremely LLM-y way as performance art. I think that's theoretically possible albeit very hard for such a long essay[2]. But if so that's also a very different performance/meta-point than the object level points he was making!
Claude thought this sounded AI-y: https://sunwords.com/2019/04/28/i-am-here-to-compete-for-your-attention/ I disagree strongly, as does Pangram. It does have some surface features like em-dashes, but other than that the tempo is very different from AI (and also different from Western blogs/essays I usually read in a way that's hard to articulate).
I had a few sentences like that here, but it's very hard to actually sustain a fully AI-slop voice while trying to distinguish yourself as clever and not actually using AI to sophisticated readers. Even dropping the second constraint, I think I'd have a lot of trouble writing the entire story in that style without any AI assistance. Pangram, naturally, flags. my essay as 100% human.