Sharing mostly because I personally didn't realize how Thiel was viewing the Bay Area rationalists these days.
He explicitly calls out Eliezer's "Death with Dignity" post as ridiculous, calls out Bostrom as out of touch, and says that the rationalists are only interesting because they aren't saying anything, and are just an echo of prevailing feelings about technology.
I think it's worthwhile really trying to step into Thiels point of view and update on it.
This feels like a conflict theory on corrupted hardware argument: AI risk people think they are guided by technical considerations, but the norm encompassing their behavior is the same as with everything else in technology, smothering progress instead of earnestly seeking a way forward, navigating the dangers.
So I think the argument is not about the technical considerations, which could well be mostly accurate, but a culture of unhealthy attitude towards them, shaping technical narratives and decisions. There's been a recent post making a point of the same kind.
Sharing mostly because I personally didn't realize how Thiel was viewing the Bay Area rationalists these days.
He explicitly calls out Eliezer's "Death with Dignity" post as ridiculous, calls out Bostrom as out of touch, and says that the rationalists are only interesting because they aren't saying anything, and are just an echo of prevailing feelings about technology.
I think it's worthwhile really trying to step into Thiels point of view and update on it.