Correction: it's examine.com not .org
Peptides that are often mentioned in the online "peptide community" (TB-4/TB-500, GHK-Cu, Tesamorelin, Ipamorelin, Tirzepatide, etc.) all have stronger evidence and "origin stories" than BPC-157. Until your post, I didn't realize that BPC's background was so shaky. Ironically, BPC is one of the most popular peptides in such communities, as far as I can tell.
Thinking through it I've come up with some possibilities for what might be going on
1. Complete Fabrication
Predrag deliberately fabricated everything, with the amino sequence being entirely random and having no real therapeutic effect. His 30 years of research are fraudulent, with collaborators having varying levels of awareness/involvement.
Unresolved Questions:
How do we explain the independent researchers in Taiwan/China/Korea? Are they complicit or just publishing invalid results?
What's the motivation behind such an elaborate and long-running scam?
Why establish a company and pursue patents if it's entirely fraudulent?
How has no one in the fitness/biohacking community noticed it's completely bunk?
2. Partial Truth with Obscured Origins
The origin story may be fabricated or obscured, but the peptide itself has genuine therapeutic benefits. His animal studies, while sometimes flawed in design, are fundamentally honest. Foreign research corroborates effectiveness.
Unresolved Questions:
What is the true source of the sequence?
Is there any real connection to gastric juices?
Why doesn't it match known proteins?
How plausible is the existence of an undiscovered stomach protein?
3. Sincere but Incompetent
Predrag genuinely believes in his work but is mistaken. The peptide is random and ineffective, with positive results stemming from poor methodology. Foreign researchers' results similarly flawed.
Unresolved Questions:
How could consistently positive results with large effect sizes persist for 30 years if the peptide is truly ineffective?
How did multiple independent researchers reach similar conclusions through flawed methods?
How has no one in the fitness/biohacking community noticed it's completely bunk?
4. Alternative Explanations
Other possibilities or complex combinations of the above scenarios not yet considered.
I'm at 10%, 25%, 50%, 15%. What about you @ChristianKl?
How could consistently positive results with large effect sizes persist for 30 years if the peptide is truly ineffective?
A majority of research studies in homeopathy find clinical effects. If you however limited yourself to high quality research papers, homeopathy seems to provide no clinical benefits. There are plenty of anecdotal reports of people getting large effect sizes from homeopathy.
It's the key argument for evidence-based medicine. Various placebo effects frequently make people believe that they have effective treatments when the treatment ... (read more)
Empiric status: I studied bioinformatics, but I'm not working in the field. I researched the article over a few months.
After reading about peptides and BPC-157 potential effects on wound healing, I decided to research BPC-157 and write this article to summarize my findings. Even if you aren’t interested in BPC-157, it’s an interesting case of a drug without FDA approval that still gets used by a few doctors, which gives us an interesting perspective on what happens when drugs get used without FDA approval.
Peptides are an interesting category. I previously argued that Orexin is promising enough to warrant experimentation and research. While there are some patents filed on peptides post-2013, the decision by the US Supreme Court to rule gene patents void makes peptide drugs derived from human peptides harder to defend, which makes them unattractive for pharma companies to investigate.
In the absence of academic studies involving human trials, the knowledge we have about the effects of peptides comes either from extrapolating animal studies or from anecdotal human reports. There are online communities like r/peptides where users share information about their experiences and give each other advice about which peptides to take.
A blogger who goes by Troof created a huge questionnaire to get people to report their experiences with various nootropics including peptides. He writes:
The concierge healthcare service, ultrapersonal healthcare, says about BPC-157:
Examine.com describes its potential benefits as:
The World Anti-Doping Agency (WADA) decided in 2022 to declare BPC-157 a prohibited substance.
Does BPC-157 actually work?
If BPC-157 works as promised, it’s a disgrace that it or an analog doesn’t get used to speed up recovery after surgery and to heal other injuries. If it works and the FDA doesn’t allow it to be marketed for this purpose, it’s bad. However, if it doesn’t work and the FDA prevents it from being used more widely, it’s a sign that the FDA is useful.
But does it work? What can we do to figure out whether it works beyond looking at academic papers on animal experiments and human reports? Instead of treating the interaction as a Black box, we can develop a gears-model of how BPC-157 would increase wound healing.
If it increases wound healing, it would likely do so by binding to receptors. The knowledge about those receptors would be valuable to develop other drugs that target the receptors and thus there are strong incentives for academic study of those receptors.
The reports of ultrapersonal healthcare and Examine.com contain no information about academic studies about the receptors with which BPC-157 interacts to produce it’s wondrous effects.
Those reports do suggest that BPC-157 is a peptide that comes out of a protein they call BPC or body protective compound. To find out more about that protein I wanted to check it out in Uniprot is a free database that contains information about all known proteins. Uniprot doesn’t contain a protein that’s named “body protective compound”.
Maybe, Uniprot just knows this protein under another name? There’s a patent from 1989 titled Pharmacologically active substance BPC, the process for its preparation and its use in the therapy that says about BPC:
While it wasn’t possible to search by sequence back in 1989, today genomes of many species are sequenced and searchable. When I search through the Uniprot database with BLAST this protein sequence doesn’t find any match. Searching over at NCBI only finds one hit out of a paper titled “Engineering recombinant Lactococcus lactis as a delivery vehicle for BPC-157 peptide with antioxidant activities” which provides no evidence that BPC exists as a natural protein.
When I wasn’t able to find the protein myself through BLAST searches I put up a question over at Biology.StackExchange about the origin of BPC-157.
Nobody, over at StackExchange could find the protein from which BCP-157 was derived either. On the other hand, Bryan Krause wrote an answer that points to other irregularities. The origin story of how the research that isolated BPC supposedly found out all its magical healing properties shortly after isolating it, isn’t credible. Research takes more time. If you want to know more about other irregularities, read the answer over there.
Most of the research comes from a single lab in Zagreb and is associated with the owner of above patent.
If the first research on BCP-157 is made up, it’s very unlikely that the later research on it is real either. The idea that a randomly made-up peptide has magic wound-healing properties is very implausible.
Drugs that have a clinical effects on humans usually do so by effecting a biological pathway in humans. If BCP-157 would help with wound healing, finding out the biological pathway through with it's having an effect would be a high priority for serious researchers. There are no claims that BCP-157 binds any existing protein. None of the papers on BCP-157 propose any biochemical mechanism by which BCP-157 interacts with biological pathways.
My best explanation of the anecdotal reports is that wound healing is a natural process and regression to the mean explains the observed healing.
The Information Environment
When I was starting my research in BCP-157, Examine.com was writing:
After I got my doubts and the above StackExchange answer was published, I sent Examine.com an email asking them to update their post on BPC-157. The paragraph now reads:
The Examine.com article didn’t update in the direction of the animal research being fraudulent. This suggests that Examine.com isn’t generally equipped to distinguish snake-oil supplements from useful supplements.
I frequently hear calls for FDA deregulation and generally feel sympathetic to them. However, if venues like examine.com aren’t able to conclude that a made-up peptide is unlikely to work, maybe FDA approval is an important element that we need to prevent our system from being overrun by sham drugs like BCP-157.
Conclusion
The lack of credible scientific evidence supporting BPC-157's effectiveness, combined with the dubious origins of its research and the financial incentives driving its promotion, casts significant doubt on its claimed benefits. Given that BPC-157 gets positive reviews from many that use it, it should make us skeptical of personal reviews of treatments and services like Examine.com.