This is a special post for quick takes by AprilSR. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
I think we should have a community norm that threatening libel suits (or actually suing) is incredibly unacceptable in almost all cases—I'm not sure what the exact exceptions should be, but maybe it should require "they were knowingly making false claims."
I feel unsure whether it would be good to enforce such a norm regarding the current Nonlinear situation because there wasn't common knowledge beforehand and because I feel too strongly about this norm to not be afraid that I'm biased (and because hearing them out is the principled thing to do). But I think building common knowledge of such a norm would be good.
I'm more confident that we should generally have norms prohibiting using threats of legal action to prevent exchange of information than I am of the exact form those norms should take. But to give my immediate thoughts:
I think the best thing for Alice to do if Bob is lying about her is to just refute the lies. In an ideal world, this is sufficient. In practice, I guess maybe it's insufficient, or maybe refuting the lies would require sharing private information, so if necessary I would next escalate to informing forum moderators, presenting evidence privat... (read more)