What? No, it can't be applied equally.
On a purely factual level: note that what I wrote was that the description as written could be applied equally to such things as "keeping promises". Once more, the quoted description:
Then getting upset at other people when they don't a take strange ritual as seriously as you do? As you've decided to, seemingly arbitrarily? When you've deliberately given them the means to upset you? It's tantamount to emotional blackmail. It's just obnoxious and strange behaviour.
This description indeed does nothing to distinguish between different norms like "keeping promises" or "taking the Petrov Day game seriously" (or, in fact, other, stupider norms such as "giving yourself electric shocks eight hours a day"). Every norm involves expecting people to choose to do something they are not [counterfactually] constrained to do, meaning every norm involves "giving someone else the means to upset you". Every norm carries with it the expectation that people will comply with it without explicit enforcement, meaning every norm is a "ritual that needs to be taken seriously". And every norm starts out being "seemingly arbitrary", until and unless it is adopted more generally, at which point it becomes "the way things are".
In other words, the OP's description is a list of conditions that always returns true, regardless of input. And as an argument that does not produce differing outputs given different inputs provides no discriminatory power, such an argument should be highlighted as bad regardless of whether you happen to agree or disagree with its target in any particular case.
(This much you know, because this much you have argued yourself elsewhere. If we are to speak of "disappointment", then I am indeed dismayed and disappointed that you in particular appear to be applying significantly less of a critical eye to comments with which you happen to share a premise, given what you've written in the past.)
Regarding the (separate and additional) argument that the Petrov Day game, and the norms surrounding it, are perhaps ill-thought-out: I don't necessarily have a strong opinion on that argument. It is plausible to me that the mods did not properly communicate the level of seriousness they expected participants to attach to the game, the last time it was played; but conversely, if their initial communications caused participants to systematically underestimate the seriousness of the game, then it is also plausible to me their response to the outcome (the website getting taken down) was a reasonable way to correct that misestimation.
There are also separate arguments to be had about whether the game ought to be treated so seriously, about its potential reputational effects and whether they are worth it, etc. etc. I am open to hearing any of those arguments. What I am not open to is the suggestion that the OP's initial description was anything but what it was: a list of conditions that apply equally to any norm, regardless of what it is, and hence an invalid line of argumentation.
Pictured Right: Enter launch codes to destroy LessWrong
Petrov Day
Today we celebrate not destroying the world. We do so today because 38 years ago, Stanislav Petrov made a decision that averted tremendous calamity. It's possible that an all-out nuclear exchange between the US and USSR would not have actually destroyed the world, but there are few things with an equal chance of doing so.
For more information see 1983 Soviet nuclear false alarm incident
Petrov is not alone in having made decisions that averted destruction–presidents, generals, commanders of nuclear submarines, and similar also made brave and fortunate calls–but Petrov's story is salient, so today we celebrate him and all those who chose equally well.
As the world progresses, likely many more people will face decisions like Petrov's. Let's celebrate in advance that they'll make good decisions! And if we expect to face decisions ourselves, let us resolve to decide wisely!
Mutually Assured Destruction (??)
The Petrov Day tradition is to celebrate Petrov's decisions and also to practice not destroying things, even when it's tempting.
In both 2019 and 2020, LessWrong placed a large red button on the frontpage and distributed "launch codes" to a few hundred "trustworthy" people. A launch would bring down the frontpage for the duration of Petrov Day, denying hundreds to thousands of people access to LessWrong. In 2019, all was fine. In 2020...let's just say some bad decisions were made.
Yet having a button on your own page that brings down your own site doesn't make much sense! Why would you have nukes pointed at yourself? It's also not very analogous to the cold war nuclear scenario between major world powers.
For those reasons, in 2021, LessWrong is teaming up with the Effective Altruism Forum to play a little game of mutual destruction. Two buttons, two sets of codes, and two sets of hopefully trustworthy users.
If LessWrong has trusted launch code recipients poorly, the EA Forum will go down, and vice versa. One of the sites going down means hundreds to thousands of people being denied to important resources: the destruction of significant real value. What's more it will damage trust between the two sites ("I guess your most trusted users couldn't be trusted to not take down our site") and also for each site itself ("I guess the admins couldn't find a hundred people who could be trusted".)
For exact rules of the game, see the final section below.
Last year it emerged that there was ambiguity about how serious the Petrov Day exercise was. I'll be clear as I can via text: there is real value on the line here and this is a real trust-building exercise that is not undertaken lightly by either LessWrong or the EA Forum. Both sites have chosen recipients who we believe we can trust to not destroy each others' communal resources.
How Do I Celebrate?
If you were one of the two hundred people to receive launch codes for LessWrong or the EA Forum, celebrate by doing nothing!
Other ways of celebrating:
Rules of the Exercise
The following email was sent last night to 100 users from LessWrong and 100 from the EA Forum:
To all, I wish you a safe and stable Petrov Day.
Here is the mirror of this post on the EA Forum. You may wish to view it for the discussion there.