This is a special post for quick takes by Richard_Ngo. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
Yeah I'm probably trying to pack too many things in together. To expand on it:
I think there's something that one can get from, for example, taking care of a garden, or a tank of shrimp, or whatever. Rationality helps a lot with it; you need to notice things, you often need to sweep away your preconceptions, you often need to rearrange how you orient to the world.
Harry really doesn't demonstrate much of that; he couldn't
keep alive a pet rock, after all.
And I think as you go thru the list of ratfic heroes, most of them also don't have these sorts of responsibilities, or have them in a way that advances the plot instead of being the plot. (Miles Vorkosigan makes a lot of his feudal duties, but I think would very much not seem like a hero to a feudal audience, instead of something more like a tribal trickster deity.)
Part of this also is that it's an ongoing relationship. You don't get your pet to a good state and then declare mission accomplished; you instead have it occupying a bit of your attention, adjusting it as necessary. There's a way it's larger than what fits into your models in a way that is often breaking and expanding them, rather than being something that you can fit into your models and brilliant path your way around. (If Ender can, thru flexibility of mind, defeat the battle school, this is, in some sense, evidence that battle school was not a strong enough enemy for Ender.)
[Maybe another take on this is: 'something to protect' as the plot instead of the character's motivation for getting good at punching is a pretty different type of story!]