This is a special post for quick takes by Richard_Ngo. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
Thank you for writing this. I thought I'd chime in with another example of this kind of thing I'd recently seen in (perhaps, contributed to) in our own work at Manifund.
A couple of months back, we were just kicking off our Falcon Fund (rapid grants for animal welfare, esp AI x animals) - see https://manifund.org/projects/falcon-fund. My original draft stated fairly strongly that the existing EA Animal Welfare Fund was dispensing money way too slowly eg couple months behind schedule for reviews; which was part of what we were excited to create Falcon. However, I was asked to remove this kind of internicine criticism from the launch post, on the grounds that (stylized) "everyone already knows that AWF is slow" and "we don't to want to scare donors and reduce even further the small amount of money AW gets"
Also, one of the animal charity founders who Marcus thought was one of the best examples of donation he's made also asked to be removed, because they did not want to be associated with EA, even though many of their donations come from EA sources.
I complied on both of these cases on a general heuristic of trying to be polite and play nice and aim to be positive sum with our counterparties, but imo these hurt Falcon's ability to raise and Manifund's general mission of increasing transparency in the ecosystem. I'm still not sure what the right call was.