This is a special post for quick takes by Richard_Ngo. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
Focusing on helping the worst-off instead of empowering the best
I feel like this is getting at some directionally correct stuff but, feels off.
EA was the union of a few disparate groups, roughly encapsulated by:
Peter Singer / Giving What We Can folk
Early Givewell
Early LessWrong
There are other specific subgroups. But, my guess is early Givewell was most loadbearing in there ending up being an "EA" identity, in that there were concrete recommendations of what to do with the money that stood up to some scrutiny. Otherwise it'd have just been more "A", or, "weird transhumanists with weird goals."
Givewell started out with a wider variety of cause areas, including education in America. It just turned out that it seemed way more obviously cost effective to do specific global health interventions than to try to fix education in America. (I realize education in America isn't particularly "empowering the best", but, the flow towards "helping worst off" seems to me like it wasn't actually the initial focus)
I agree some memeplex accreted around that, which had some of the properties you describe.
But meanwhile:
EA started off with global health and ended up pivoting hard to AI safety, AI governance, etc.
It seems off to say "started off in global health, and pivoted to AI", when all the AI stuff was there from the beginning at the very first pre-EA-Global events, and just eventually became clear that it was real, and important. The worldview that generated AI was not (exactly) the same one generating global health, they were just two clusters of worldview that were in conversation with each other from the beginning.