This is a special post for quick takes by Richard_Ngo. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
In times of UDT2, the background assumption was that agents should maintain an unchanging preference, which is separate from knowledge. One motivation for UDT is that updating makes an agent stop caring about updated-away possibilities, while UDT is not doing that. Going back to a previous epistemic state is a way of preserving preference from that epistemic state, the "current" utility function is considered a bug and doesn't do anything if UDT is adopted. The non-updated agent can in principle consider the information you currently have as one of the possibilities when formulating the general policy for all possibilities, though being bounded it won't do a very good job.
Traditionally UDT1.1 wants to make its decisions from very little knowledge and to apply the policy to all always. A more pragmatic thing is to make decisions from modestly less knowledge and to scope the policy for middle-term future. Some form of this is useful for many thought experiments where the environment or other players also have the little knowledge our agent uses to make its decisions from the past, and so could know the policy the agent decides on before they need to prepare for it or make predictions about it.
The problem is commitment races (as in the game of chicken), where everyone wants to decide earlier and force the others to respond. But there is a need to remain bounded in making decisions, both to personally compute them and to make it possible for others to anticipate them and to coordinate. This creates a more reasonable equilibrium, motivating decisions from a less ignorant epistemic state that have a better chance of being relevant to the current situation, in balance with trying to decide from a more ignorant epistemic state where a general policy would enable more strategicness across possibilities. UDT1.1 can't find such balance, but it's possible that something UDT2-shaped might.