This is a special post for quick takes by Richard_Ngo. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
Thanks for chiming in with this. People criticizing the epistemics is hopefully how we get better epistemics. When the Californian smoke isn't interfering with my cognition as much, I'll try to give your feedback (and Rohin's) proper attention. I would generally be interested to hear your arguments/models in detail, if you get the chance to lay them out.
My default position is LW has done well enough historically (e.g. Ben Pace's examples) for me to currently be investing in getting it even better. Epistemics and progress could definitely be a lot better, but getting there is hard. If I didn't see much progress on the rate of progress in the next year or two, I'd probably go focus on other things, though I think it'd be tragic if we ever lost what we have now.
And another thought:
And we're trying to produce reliable answers to much harder questions by, what, writing better blog posts
Yes and no. Journal articles have their advantages, and so do blog posts. A bunch of recent LessWrong team's work has been around filling in the missing pieces for the system to work, e.g. Open Questions (hasn't yet worked for coordinating research), Annual Review, Tagging, Wiki. We often talk about conferences and "campus". My work on Open Questions involved thinking about i) a better template for articles than "Abstract, Intro, Methods, etc.", but Open Questions didn't work for unrelated reasons we haven't overcome yet, ii) getting lit reviews done systematically by people, iii) coordinating groups around research agendas.
I've thought about re-attempting the goals of Open Questions with instead a "Research Agenda" feature that lets people communally maintain research agendas and work on them. It's a question of priorities whether I work on that anytime soon.
I do really think many of the deficiencies of LessWrong's current work compared to academia are "infrastructure problems" at least as much as the epistemic standards of the community. Which means the LW team should be held culpable for not having solved them yet, but it is tricky.