This is a special post for quick takes by Richard_Ngo. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
The kinds of virtue that would make me comfortable with an organization doing a bunch of dual-use research seem pretty strongly anticorrelated with decisions like rescinding my offer. AI alignment will only become more central to the coming power struggles over AI, and being willing to give in to vague concerns about potential hires doesn't bode well for Resolution's ability to navigate those struggles in high-integrity ways.
I just wanted to say, as a guy sometimes sketched out or confused by Richard's politics, I agree with this.
I feel particularly worried about it about dual use, but, that's maybe just a subsection of: If Resolution is trying to be a place doing world class intellectual work, people there will need to think thoughts that go in directions that don't fit consensus, which are correlated with people finding uncomfortable.
I realize most of what it's trying to do is in a STEM-y frame that you might theoretically hope is orthogonal to politics. But I expect a lot of people to do their thinking about solving superalignment as part of their thinking about AI macrostrategy, and in general the lines here are kind of blurry.
I also just think... from a sorta normal politics standpoint... The fact that the US is forking into two sides that can't coexist with each other is part of the problem. If your org culture can't talk to people like Richard, you are implicitly throwing out like half of America?
There are several different reasons it seems valuable to be proactively setting a culture of "we can talk about a wide variety of ideas here."
idk there's a longer better comment here I want to write but don't really have time atm.