This is a special post for quick takes by Richard_Ngo. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
Yeah the better comment I'd like to have written engages more with the tradeoffs here. I totally agree there are (or at least might be) real tradeoffs here.
I would not guess that all of these are true, but I wouldn't be so confident without, for example, having talked to several potential hires for the org.
Absolutely I expect there to be potential hires who are turned off. But, I think the current amount that people expect to be able to work at companies without dealing with people who have politics that feel crazy and bad, are waaaaaaaaaaaay out of whack. (I'm not sure if you disagree particularly or are just pointing out the obvious failure modes and issues).
I don't actually know that I think Resolution should do something different, given the existing founders and culture at Resolution. I think I am advocating or wishing for a high-skill culturebuilding maneuver that is not, like, a free action anyone can just take.
But, I think it is a negative sign abut their capability as an intellectual org, if they aren't able or willing to do the culture-setting moves I'd be hoping for here.