This is a special post for quick takes by Richard_Ngo. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
I don't think that's insane! But I think at a policy level refusing to coordinate/work with 70%-ish of the population (if you are being symmetric about it) is probably a pretty bad mistake? At least for this kind of stuff.
Like, seems like this would be an orthogonal dimension from competence, intelligence, integrity and other things you also want to select on, so seems like you would be very heavily constraining the set of people you would want to collaborate with. Which I mean you can do, there are a lot of people, but does seem like it would be super costly, and in some sense non-viable (like, it's hard to maintain any kind of cooperative stance towards the world if you consider the majority, or close to the majority of people to have opinions so reprehensible you need to actively distance yourself from them).