I noticed in myself that the social filter on what you say is so ingrained that the internal experience of having nothing to say in a social setting is already post-filter, such that it feels like a failure of thought generation. A fix is to pay attention to what you expect the other person is paying attention to, so that what you naturally think already lives in the same attentional world as theirs. Which might be what conversational compatibility/flow is about.
This is also part of why meditation and/or therapy are helpful for debugging. It's hard to catch trapped priors in the moment, but if you learn to slow down your thought processes and/or bring up a situation later so a skilled interlocutor can analyze it, your brain will slowly release its vice grip on your experience and allow you to actually observe what's going on (and decide whether you want it to continue.)