bodry's Shortform

bodry

This is a special post for quick takes by bodry. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.

I've made a timeline of the federal takeover of DC that I plan to update daily.

https://plosique.substack.com/p/timeline-of-the-federal-takeover

This is a well-documented event so I've not making this a full link post. I grew up and currently live in Northern Virginia and I've made several visits to DC since the takeover. It feels significant and definitely feels like it could grow into something very significant. I am not supportive of the takeover but there's more nuance than the coverage of it (no surprise there). A bird eye's view has been helpful in thinking about it and arguing with the people I know who are supportive of it.

1bodry1y

I've stopped posting this timeline. Here's a summary for closure: The emergency ended on September 10th. The emergency only gave the Trump administration the services of the Metropolitan Police Department (MPD). The Trump administration did try to replace the MPD Chief with an emergency one but the courts prevented it. The National Guard troops will remain until at least until December. These troops are from the DC National Guard and the National Guard from several red states. They total around 2000. Another Executive Order was passed in late August that created a number of units including: a rapid response National Guard unit (not deputized) and a deputized public safety unit. Both units are intended for deployment in DC and elsewhere. There is still a pretty large presence of federal agents in DC and they are doing a lot of arresting. According to the Attorney General Pam Bondi about 1500 people were arrested in the month of August by federal agents which is on par with the 20,000 arrested by the MPD each year. DC Mayor Bowser created the Safe and Beautiful Operations Center to ensure coordination with federal law enforcement to the "maximum extent allowable within the district." DC statutes still make it a "sanctuary" city but there is a bill that passed the House to eliminate those statutes and prevent the DC council from passing similar ones. Here is a good legal analysis of the takeover.

Some other context:
The DC Attorney General is currently suing the Trump administration on several grounds including a violation of the Posse Comitatus Act (PCA). PCA prevents the military from being used as law enforcement unless an express exception is provided in the Constitution or in an Act of Congress. Its significant that the Trump administration has already lost a case on the grounds that they violated the PCA. In Newsom vs Trump Trump's lawyers mainly argued for a Constitutional exception to the PCA that permits the US military to... (read more)

4Dean Valentine1y

I actually find that they do appear in the New York Times and other newspapers a lot.