1282

LESSWRONG
LW

1281
Ukraine/Russia Conflict (2022)Forecasts (Specific Predictions)World Modeling
Personal Blog

3

Russia will do a nuclear test

by sanxiyn
4th Oct 2022
1 min read
7

3

3

Russia will do a nuclear test
7bokov
7Viliam
4Big Tony
3Tetraspace
2Pialgo
6sanxiyn
0Big Tony
New Comment
7 comments, sorted by
top scoring
Click to highlight new comments since: Today at 3:19 AM
[-]bokov3y70

How would a nuclear test demonstrate that Putin is not bluffing?

It only demonstrates that he has nukes, which we already know.

Reply
[-]Viliam3y77

It would stop people joking "I bet their nukes probably aren't working either".

I don't think that the military takes these jokes seriously. But for the general population of NATO countries, this kind of humor helps reduce the anxiety about WW3. A nuclear test would help restore the anxiety.

Reply
[-]Big Tony3y46

Conducting a nuclear test indicates a much higher willingness to use nuclear than just keeping them in storage does.

Reply
[-]Tetraspace3y30

Relevant Manifold: Will Russia conduct a nuclear test during 2022?, currently at 26%.

Reply
[-]Pialgo3y20

Not sure if it considered a "international law" but there are treaties about nuclear testing : 

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_weapons_testing#Treaties_against_testing

Like this one : 

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comprehensive_Nuclear-Test-Ban_Treaty

Now, I'm curious about what the community will think if you put it on metaculus, could be interresting.

Reply
[-]sanxiyn3y60

As the article explains, CTBT is not in force.

Reply
[-]Big Tony3y00

A thought occurred to me, and it's so logical, I concluded that it must be true.


Is this satire?

Russia will detonate a nuclear weapon in Russia. In other words, Russia will do a nuclear test. Like North Korea did.

With (literally) a nuclear option, pushing the nuclear button is a last resort.
The path there is through various escalations, without any individual step being too overt.

For example, if Putin wants to demonstrate their willingness to use nuclear weapons, he can:

  1. Create unusual movement/activity at one of their nuclear bases, in a way that it is visible to other countries
  2. Carry out a nuclear test inside Russia
  3. Carry out a nuclear test in some deserted area outside of Russia
  4. Carry out testing of the delivery mechanism (ICBM? Via airplane?) just without a nuclear warhead
  5. Carry out a nuclear test close to/on the Ukraine border
  6. Use nuclear weapons in 'his' territory (the illegally-annexed areas of Ukraine) to put down 'illegal' resistance
Reply
Moderation Log
More from sanxiyn
View more
Curated and popular this week
7Comments
Ukraine/Russia Conflict (2022)Forecasts (Specific Predictions)World Modeling
Personal Blog

A thought occurred to me, and it's so logical, I concluded that it must be true.

Russia will not detonate a nuclear weapon in Ukraine, fearing repercussion.

Russia will detonate a nuclear weapon in Russia. In other words, Russia will do a nuclear test. Like North Korea did.

As far as I know, there is no international law against Russia doing a nuclear test. Russia is a recognized nuclear weapon state of NPT, unlike North Korea. The test will give weight to Putin's words that he is not bluffing.