LESSWRONG
LW

Personal Blog

5

2005 short story loosely about P-zombies

by Airedale
24th Nov 2010
1 min read
3

5

Personal Blog

5

2005 short story loosely about P-zombies
2cata
2Manfred
1Nisan
New Comment
3 comments, sorted by
top scoring
Click to highlight new comments since: Today at 6:31 AM
[-]cata15y20

A neatly written story. After the immediate setup, the thing that struck me most as unusual and intriguing is that the author assumes a qualitative difference between, on the one hand, "having access" to your memories and experience (and your other brain function) and, on the other hand, really having that experience be a "part of" you, helping to construct your personality. I'm not sure that difference makes any sense at all, but it fits with the picture he paints of a mind that is just composed of little actors with internal structure, one of the actors being your "self."

Reply
[-]Manfred15y20

Gregory's version of consciousness seems to be pretty causally important to me. After all, when your consciousness changes, you act like a totally different person!

So the story doesn't end up being about p-zombies, but is still pretty interesting. Or, perhaps, is interesting because it's not about p-zombies.

Reply
[-]Nisan15y10

This story is not so much about p-zombies as about death and birth of subagents.

Reply
Moderation Log
More from Airedale
View more
Curated and popular this week
3Comments

I thought some of you might enjoy this 2005 story published in Asimov's:

Second Person, Present Tense by Daryl Gregory (plus some of the author's notes on the story)

The story involves a a drug that (for a period of time) turns someone into a P-zombie.

It's currently available for free on the Asimov's page, but it may only be there temporarily.