Honestly, this is such a bad reply by Scott that I… don’t quite know whether I want to work on all of this anymore.
If this is how this ecosystem wants to treat people trying their hardest to communicate openly about the risks, and who are trying to somehow make sense of the real adversarial pressures they are facing, then I don't think I want anything to do with it.
I have issues with Rob's top-level tweet. I think it gets some things wrong, but it points at a real dynamic. It’s kind of strawman-y about things, and this makes some of Scott’s reaction more understandable, but his response overall seems enormously disproportionate.
Scott's response is extremely emblematic of what I've experienced in the space. Simultaneous extreme insults and obviously bad faith arguments ("actually, it's your fault that Deepmind was founded because you weren't careful enough with your comms"), and then gaslighting that no one faces any censure for being open about these things (despite the very thing you are reading being extremely aggro about the lack of strategic communication), and actually we should be happy that Ilya started another ASI lab, and that Jan Leike has some compute budget.
The whole "no you are actually responsible for Deepmind" thing, in a tweet defending that it's great that all of our resources are going into Anthropic, is just totally absurd. I don't know what is going on with Scott here, but this is clearly not a high-quality response.
Copying my replies from Twitter, but I am also seriously considering making this my last day. It's not the kind of decision to be made at 5AM in the morning so who knows, but seriously, fuck this.
IMO this doesn't seem like the kind of response you will endorse in a few days, especially the "You are responsible for Deepmind/OpenAI" part.
You were also talking about AI close to the same time, and you've historically been pretty principled about this kind of stance.
you could argue that you're not against strategicness in general, just talking about this one issue of saying cleanly that AI is very dangerous.
Robby at least has been very consistent on this that he is against most forms of strategic communication in general.
I also think you are against many forms of strategic communication in general? Your writing explores many of the relevant considerations in a lot of depth, and you certainly have not shied away from sharing your opinion on controversial issues, even when it wasn't super clear how that is going to help things.
I think you are just arguing the wrong side of this specific argument branch. My model of Eliezer, Nate and Robby all have been pretty consistent that being overly strategic in conversation usually backfires. Of course you shouldn't have no strategy, and my model of Eliezer in-particular has been in the past too strategic for my tastes and so might disagree with this, but I am pretty confident Robby himself is just pretty solidly on the "it's good to blurt out what you believe, *especially* if you don't have any good confident inside view model about how to make things better".
In exchange, we would have won a couple more years of timeline, which would have been pointless, because timeline isn't measured in distance from the year 1 AD, it's measured in distance between some level of woken-up-ness and some point of danger, and the woken-up-ness would be pushed forward at the same rate the danger was.
I feel like we both know this is a strawman. The key thing at least in recent years that Rob, Eliezer and Nate have been arguing for is the political machinery necessary to actually control how fast you are building ASI, and the ability to stop for many years at a time, and to only proceed when risks actually seem handled.
If anything, Eliezer, Nate and Robby have been actively trying to move political will from "a pause right now" to "the machinery for a genuine stop".
This makes this comparison just weird. Yes, according to everyone's models the only time you might have the political will to stop will be in the future. I have never seen Nate or Eliezer or Robby say that they expect to get a stop tomorrow. But they of course also know that getting in a position to stop takes a long time, and the right time to get started on that work was yesterday.
So if they had their way (with their present selves teleported back in time) is that we would have more draft treaties, more negotiation between the U.S. and China. More materials ready to hand congress people who are trying to grapple with all of this stuff. Essays and books and movies and videos explaining the AI existential risk case straightforwardly to every audience imaginable.
That is what you could do if you took the 200+ risk-concerned people who ended up instead going to work at Anthropic, or ended up trying to play various inside-game politics things at OpenAI.
And man, I don't know, but that just seems like a much better world. Maybe you disagree, which is fine, but please don't create a strawman where Robby or Nate or Eliezer were ever really centrally angling for a short-termed pause that would have already passed by-then.
And then even beyond that, I think if you don't know how to solve a problem, I think it is generally the virtuous thing to help other people get more surface area on solving it. Buying more time is the best way to do that, especially buying time now when the risks are pretty intuitive. I think you believe this too, and I don't really know what's going with your reaction here.
But my impression is that the rest of the field is executing this portfolio plan admirably, but MIRI and a few other PauseAI people are trying to sabotage every other strategy in the portfolio in the hope of forcing people into theirs.
Come on man, a huge number of people we both respect have recently updated that the kind of direct advocacy that MIRI has been doing has been massively under-invested in. I do not think that "other people are executing this portfolio plan admirably", and this is just such a huge mischaracterization of the dynamics of this situation that I don't know where to start.
"If Anyone Builds It, Everyone Dies" is a straightforward book. It doesn't try to sabotage every other strategy in the portfolio, and I have no idea how you could characterize really any of the media appearances of Nate this way.
This is of course in contrast to Open Phil defunding almost everyone who has been pursuing this strategy and making mine and tons of other people's lives hell, and all kinds of complicated adversarial shit that I've been having to deal with for years, where absolutely there have been tons of attempts to sabotage people trying to pursue strategies like this.
Like man, we can maybe argue about the magnitude of the errors here, and the sabotage or whatever, but trying to characterize this as some kind of "Nate, Eliezer, Robby are defecting on other people trying to be purely cooperative" seems absurd to me. I am really confused what is going on here.
We wouldn't have the head of the leading AI lab writing letters to policymakers begging them to "jolt awake", we wouldn't have a substantial fraction of world compute going to Jan Leike's alignment efforts, we wouldn't have Ilya sitting on $50 billion for some super-secret alignment project
I am sympathetic to the first of these (but disagree you are characterizing Dario here correctly).
But come on, clearly Ilya sitting on $50 billion for starting another ASI company is not good news for the world. I don't think you believe that this is actually a real ray of hope.
(And then I also don't think that Jan Leike having marginally more compute is going to help, but maybe there is a more real disagreement here)
Overall, I am so so so tired of the gaslighting here.