Thanks. For the record I disagree with both 1 and 2; I do not think it is at ALL clear that LLMs lack some of the important cognitive algorithms that humans possess and have not gotten better at them over the years. Very unclear at best. Two people's self reports of anecdotes of failure is not enough to clearly establish this.
For 2, well... why do you think it's at least as hard as the hardest cognitive project humanity has historically accomplished? There are some skills LLMs structurally can't have, apparently, according to your premise 1. But maybe there's a somewhat different AI architecture that can have those skills. Why should it be so incredibly hard to find?