This is a special post for quick takes by Character#2736. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
What is one to do when someone genuinely says "I know my views are contradictory, but...", "I'm never going to accept that because it just feels wrong!", or other statements in that vein? It's even worse if they're otherwise sensible or intelligent.
In the sort of case where the conclusion is essentially a moral judgement, it's perfectly reasonable and even expected. If judgements A, B, C actually imply D, and D is morally unacceptable to a particular person then a rational conclusion is that one or more of A, B, C are wrong, even if they can't specifically say which ones.