cw rape
Context:
I am upset. I am all for a free market of ideas, but some goods are ones we can choose not to buy and sell. Several of these people feel pretty rationalist in nature and I feel gaslit/uncertain. Are we a community who, when someone is thrown out of Lighthaven our response is to be like 'maybe he should be given a free ticket to manifest' and if I accuse someone of a felony, our response is 'hmmm that's probably free speech and cancellation'?
I dunno, is that the kind of community we are?
I acknowledge I am being emotional, but I am emotional. It seems important to me that I can know that people in my community will not be so flippant as to ignore red flags this large.
That reminds me of people who upvote an article that even they think sucks, just because in their opinion others have downvoted it too much. Vote by your true opinion; don't be your neighbor's utility minimizer.
Cynically speaking, consider the incentives: by defending a rapist, you get your contrarian points... and someone else pays the price (including the reputational price for the organizers).
I dunno, is that the kind of community we are?
Contrarianism is valued too highly here. Not just when it happens to be correct, but per se. That's a mistake.