In my view, the biggest limitation of the Logical Inductor lies in its failure to satisfy Desiderata 15 and 17. What is the ultimate value of a system if it lacks metacognition—the ability to determine on its own which problems are genuinely important—and fails to emulate the way human collective intelligence solves problems (akin to how Einstein’s theories revolutionized Newtonian mechanics)?
I believe an algorithm capable of distinguishing between a "larger problem" and a "smaller problem" is necessary. For instance, to prove that "primes are infinite," one must first establish that "natural numbers are infinite," with the latter being an explicitly "smaller" problem. I felt the paper did not sufficiently address this methodology.
To use a military analogy, the paper reads like a tactical manual that only instructs on "how to charge." While it may guarantee victory in theory, strictly adhering to it in practice would result in total annihilation before advancing even a single meter. The true significance of this paper lies in its enabling of "friend-or-foe identification." In other words, it prevents the system from falling into self-contradiction—a logical trap caused by miscalculating probabilities when unable to discern whether an unfamiliar mathematical formula is true or false.
Put simply, it reconciles beliefs so that logical propositions do not contradict one another. Given infinite time, its judgments are practically indistinguishable from having complete, pre-existing information (much like the relationship between 1 and 0.999). Returning to the military metaphor, this could be expressed as: "Our troops won't engage in friendly fire, and if time and resources are infinite, there is no terrain we cannot overrun!"
The mechanism for achieving this is akin to hiring more part-time auditors than the actual number of soldiers, rewarding them whenever they catch a soldier breaking formation. This reward is deducted from the soldiers' pay, and the ultimate goal of the Logical Inductor is to reduce this "payout" to zero dollars. The reason the Logical Inductor is rarely discussed in modern computing environments is that the industry views the Scaling Law as far more efficient—preferring to allocate computational resources toward expanding the number of "troops" rather than investing in "auditors." Granted, this means the formation may become disorganized (i.e., hallucinations will occur). This aligns perfectly with Richard Sutton’s insight in The Bitter Lesson: "The biggest lesson that can be read from 70 years of AI research is that general methods that leverage computation are ultimately the most effective, and by a large margin."
Following logical induction, subsequent research should have focused on guiding these "traders" to incorporate accumulated mathematical proofs from the outset, rather than forcing them to learn completely from scratch through trial and error. I am aware that such research does exist. While many blindly worship the Scaling Law, if we look at the next 30 years of mathematical progress and ask whether we should "support a mathematician like Terence Tao or build another data center" (assuming equivalent costs), the pragmatic choice would undoubtedly be the former. This is a bitter truth that Big Tech must eventually confront. In that regard, I completely agree that if we ever want to reach a point where "building a data center is cheaper than supporting the greatest mathematician of our time for 30 years to advance pure mathematics," we must pursue research in the direction of logical induction rather than relying solely on the Scaling Law.