I always assumed rationalists were health optimizers. I'm not a rationalist, and I kinda assumed that the people who reason carefully about everything would surely reason carefully about what they put in their bodies. And after all, isn't it "rational" to try to live longer, so that you can gain more "utility" from more years of life?
Then I arrived at Lighthaven, where the rationalist community holds its conferences and retreats.
The first thing I noticed were the plastic water bottles everywhere. Did people not mind the microplastics entering their bloodstreams?? And the snacks: kettle chips, Swedish fish, the kind of dried mangoes that have added sugar...
To be clear, I'm not judging. I consume plenty of microplastics and sugary snacks myself. But I was surprised.
To add fuel to the fire, I then heard a rumor that a bunch of rationalists were addicted to nicotine. Isn't that good for your short-term focus, but bad for your long-term health? (To be fair, they were apparently inspired by a post that Gwern wrote, citing a bunch of scientific studies about how nicotine gum isn't actually that bad for you... but still.)
That's when I began to wonder: maybe people consider it rational to take stimulants that boost their short-term mental energy, at the cost of their longevity. Especially if they believe there's a good chance that AI is going to kill us all within the next decade. Maybe under that framework, prioritizing longevity is actually irrational?
So today, I decided to send out a survey on this. I distributed it in the Lighthaven Slack and on Twitter.
Only twenty-nine people have answered thus far, but unfortunately—as I am here for a writing residency and will be kicked out if I don't publish my blog post by tonight—this is all the data we'll have to go off of.
how many respondents were rationalists?
I asked everyone how much they self-identified as a rationalist. Just under half -- 12 out of 29 -- rated themselves 5 or higher out of 7. I will consider those 12 as "rationalists."
do rationalists care about longevity?
I also asked everyone: how much effort do you invest in optimizing your longevity?
The people who scored themselves higher on rationality also reported more effort on longevity. With a sample this small I expected nothing to hold up, but this one correlation did (Spearman 0.38, p = 0.04) (thanks Claude for the analysis).
are they actually addicted to nicotine?
No. Most people just take caffeine. 4 respondents use nicotine; 6 take a prescription stimulant (e.g. Adderall). There was no significant difference between the rationalist and non-rationalist group.
conclusion
Unfortunately, the survey failed to shed meaningful light on my hypothesis. Maybe I'm totally wrong, or maybe I just need to talk to some more people.
If you are a rationalist and want to share any personal anecdotes on whether it’s rational to care about your longevity, feel free to DM me :)
My personal vibes on this (not backed up by calculated analysis) is that our uncertainty is super high. Nutrition science is far less of a science than practitioners claim, especially when discussing long term impacts of what we eat. Causational studies over 20 years are non existent. Observational studies are hopelessly confounded. Metabolism is hopelessly complex.
There are some things that are obviously good. Don't be obese. Don't be constantly high on sugar. Eat sufficient protein and essential vitamins and minerals. Beyond that we don't have much of a clue, and to the extent these things have an impact, the impact of each individual consumption event is low. Meanwhile chips and sweets taste delicious and not eating them takes willpower. Willpower is scarce. I'll use it for things where I'm more certain of the effect.
There are however low cost high impact things I can do in the sphere. Not eating sweets when someone puts them out in front of me is hard. Not buying sweets is easy, and reduces my consumption over the long term, not just a one off event. Not using plastic water bottles is annoying, but using china and metal utensils at home instead of plastic is both easy and more pleasant. When I heat something up in the microwave I cover it with a plate instead of clingfilm. etc.
I always assumed rationalists were health optimizers. I'm not a rationalist, and I kinda assumed that the people who reason carefully about everything would surely reason carefully about what they put in their bodies. And after all, isn't it "rational" to try to live longer, so that you can gain more "utility" from more years of life?
Then I arrived at Lighthaven, where the rationalist community holds its conferences and retreats.
The first thing I noticed were the plastic water bottles everywhere. Did people not mind the microplastics entering their bloodstreams?? And the snacks: kettle chips, Swedish fish, the kind of dried mangoes that have added sugar...
To be clear, I'm not judging. I consume plenty of microplastics and sugary snacks myself. But I was surprised.
To add fuel to the fire, I then heard a rumor that a bunch of rationalists were addicted to nicotine. Isn't that good for your short-term focus, but bad for your long-term health? (To be fair, they were apparently inspired by a post that Gwern wrote, citing a bunch of scientific studies about how nicotine gum isn't actually that bad for you... but still.)
That's when I began to wonder: maybe people consider it rational to take stimulants that boost their short-term mental energy, at the cost of their longevity. Especially if they believe there's a good chance that AI is going to kill us all within the next decade. Maybe under that framework, prioritizing longevity is actually irrational?
So today, I decided to send out a survey on this. I distributed it in the Lighthaven Slack and on Twitter.
Only twenty-nine people have answered thus far, but unfortunately—as I am here for a writing residency and will be kicked out if I don't publish my blog post by tonight—this is all the data we'll have to go off of.
how many respondents were rationalists?
I asked everyone how much they self-identified as a rationalist. Just under half -- 12 out of 29 -- rated themselves 5 or higher out of 7. I will consider those 12 as "rationalists."
do rationalists care about longevity?
I also asked everyone: how much effort do you invest in optimizing your longevity?
The people who scored themselves higher on rationality also reported more effort on longevity. With a sample this small I expected nothing to hold up, but this one correlation did (Spearman 0.38, p = 0.04) (thanks Claude for the analysis).
are they actually addicted to nicotine?
No. Most people just take caffeine. 4 respondents use nicotine; 6 take a prescription stimulant (e.g. Adderall). There was no significant difference between the rationalist and non-rationalist group.
conclusion
Unfortunately, the survey failed to shed meaningful light on my hypothesis. Maybe I'm totally wrong, or maybe I just need to talk to some more people.
If you are a rationalist and want to share any personal anecdotes on whether it’s rational to care about your longevity, feel free to DM me :)