No, you should not fault them for any of it. If you are healthy and not taking regular medicine, the initial assumption — that you have to talk to your doctor about supplements — is wrong.
Yes, doctors should follow up on current research but also prioritize what is most relevant. How to have a slight effect on common infections and influenza is definitely not top of mind. Cross-medication effects for the elderly are just one example of much more relevant research to stay on top of, amid a myriad of topics.
You are definitely not supposed to have papers printed out for them. You might refer to a study you read, yes, but bringing print-outs is over the top even if you are a colleague of some sort. If you feel confident in a chatbot's advice for something not remotely life-threatening — go ahead! And during your next regular visit inform your doctor of your decisions and any supplements you take (just as you would with OTC medicine) — but don't expect a professional discussion. Also: doctors have the same range as any other profession, so the chance of having a mediocre one follows the bell curve.
Sidenote: your cited study is rather old. Has there been no new research since 1997? This would indicate it is not something the medical community feels is worth following up on.
One likely explanation to me seems to be that there is low confidence in achieving results that prove the suggested "extremely huge" impact, and an inherent risk of being reduced to the efficiency level of chicken soup.
That sounds to me like you haven't really thought about the case. NAC has a well validated effect for clinical practice and is a routine medication and running the study for what is essentially off-label use of NAC wouldn't discourage the on-label use of it which is driving most of the sales.
When ill the body needs cysteine both for glutathi... (read more)
As you are supposed to ask your doctor about supplements, I just asked my primary care doctor about taking glycine and N-acetylcysteine.
I had a lot more infections in the last two years and I'm doing some fascia work that could increase collagen turnover, so there's reasoning in that time frame that would be a causal explanation for increased glycine usage for collagen generation and less leftover for glutathione production.
My doctor just said, she doesn't know of any evidence for either supplement helping with immune function.
Should I fault her for not knowing about De Flora et al 1997 finding that N-acetylcysteine helps prophylactically to prevent influenza from becoming symptomatic? Should I fault her for not knowing that chicken bone broth soup has been shown in the last evidence review to be helpful for reducing the length of acute respiratory tract infections, and its glycine content being a prime causal explanation?
Should I fault her for not knowing that much about glutathione, as it doesn't come up that much in her daily practice?
Are you supposed to have the papers printed out to hand them to your doctor, or what are you supposed to do in a situation like that?
If you are doing are thinking about taking any non-standard interventions that are far away from the normal practice of medicine, why would you assume that the average doctor can tell you about the merit of the intervention?
Chatbots aren't perfect but they have access to a lot more information and if you talk to them about specific studies they can easily engage with you. You can push back. You can continue a conversation over multiple days when you first conversation made you more aware of other symptoms. You can ask another chatbot to check the work of the first one.