308

LESSWRONG
LW

307
Practical
Personal Blog

3

Boston Contra: Fully Gender-Free

by jefftk
10th Apr 2022
jefftk
1 min read
12

3

Practical
Personal Blog

3

Boston Contra: Fully Gender-Free
7Stephen Bennett
5Zac Hatfield-Dodds
4jefftk
2Gunnar_Zarncke
2jefftk
2Gunnar_Zarncke
4jefftk
6Gunnar_Zarncke
6ChristianKl
6jefftk
2Gunnar_Zarncke
1Stephen Bennett
New Comment
12 comments, sorted by
top scoring
Click to highlight new comments since: Today at 10:08 PM
[-]Stephen Bennett3y70

Perhaps I'm displaying an astounding amount of ignorance by asking, but what does gender-free mean?

Reply
[-]Zac Hatfield-Dodds3y50

Short form of "in partner dances which traditionally have different roles for men and women, anyone can dance either role regardless of their gender".

Reply
[-]jefftk3y40

And, specifically, that the role terms don't reference gender.

(The dances have already been places where people can dance either role if they want to for a while)

Reply
[-]Gunnar_Zarncke3y20

What effect does this have on the dance moves? Intersection or union of raven and lark moves?

Reply
[-]jefftk3y20

The dance is the same. The roles are just Larks/Ravens (or Robins) instead of Gents/Ladies.

Reply
[-]Gunnar_Zarncke3y20

So both have to be able to dance both roles?

Reply
[-]jefftk3y40

No: anyone can choose which role to dance. Gender-free terminology is about making it clear that you can dance either roll regardless of your gender, but it doesn't mean anyone will have to dance a different role than they want.

Any time the caller would have said Ladies/Women, now they say Robins (or Ravens), while any time they previously would have said Gents/Men, now they say Larks. The difference is really quite small, but it's very important to a lot of people.

Reply
[-]Gunnar_Zarncke3y60

So it is just nomenclature - and here I thought it was a change to the dance that allowed all lark/raven combinations.

Reply
[-]ChristianKl3y60

It's nomenclature to signal the social permission that anyone can take any role they like. It's a statement that it's socially okay for a man to decide to take the Ravens role.

Reply
[-]jefftk3y60

It's an incredibly controversial change to nomenclature ;)

Reply
[-]Gunnar_Zarncke3y20

I assume sometimes small changes have big effects...

Reply
[-]Stephen Bennett3y10

My impression from reading Zac and jeff's comments is that it is a change in the labels of the roles in dance, not a change in the dancing itself.

Reply
Moderation Log
More from jefftk
View more
Curated and popular this week
12Comments

There are currently four contra dance series in Boston: LCFD, BIDA, Concord Thursday, and Concord Monday Fundraisers. And all four are gender-free!

This has been a long time coming. Boston's gender-free contras started with JP's LCFD in 1988. BIDA discussions started in 2013 and we switched in 2017. Monday fundraisers have been Larks/Robins since before covid, and the Thursday dance is going gender-free as they restart.

Since I don't know what regular Concord Monday is planning for when they restart this may be a temporary situation. But it's an exciting milestone regardless!