This is a special post for quick takes by Eric Neyman. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
Suppose that you generally prefer Democrats to Republicans, but Republicans nominate Randy, who's an above-average Republican, for president, while Democrats nominate Donna, a below-average Democrat, for president, such that you're actually roughly neutral between them.
Even though you think Randy and Donna would be about equally good as president, I claim that you should vote for Randy. That's because, if Randy becomes president, he's "locked in" as their party's nominee in the next presidential election, which is great from your perspective. You'd much rather the next presidential election be contested between Randy and a generic Democrat, than between Donna and a generic Republican.
This difference can be important enough that you might sometimes want to vote for Randy even if you actually prefer Donna as president by a small-to-medium amount.
(This of course works symmetrically if you switch the two parties in my example.)
Two more reasons to vote for Randy:
1. It gives both parties a signal to move in the direction you prefer. The Republicans might get the message that voters prefer Randy-like representatives and all move in that direction. Meanwhile the Democrats get the signal to move away from Donna back to positions you prefer.
2. If Randy was a good enough candidate that you're considering voting for him despite you generally preferring Democrats, he might actually be a better candidate overall.
3WhatsTrueKittycat
I do not entirely disagree with the hypothetical case as stated (and probably should have made that clearer). But in applying this hypothetical to the real-world, one cannot avoid the reference class problem, and in my opinion second-order effects such as appointed officials and the policies each party is liable to put forward (and which Randy and Donna might have incentives to veto) alter the dynamic significantly. If you are indeed "supposing that they are of similar quality after taking into account the[se] dynamic[s]", then sure, IF your hypothetical conditions obtain, there is an argument for Randy. This is absurdly distant from anything we seem likely to actually see in upcoming elections, and I think your avoidance of object-level claims regarding the parties demonstrates that this post is operating entirely within the spherical-politician-in-a-vacuum regime (which occupies measure zero in the space of real world politics).
I think that, while many LessWrong readers do believe that one party is way better than the other, such that the inter-party quality variation is far larger than the intra-party quality variation, this is not true of all readers.
And I think it's a reasonable move to write a post that says "Assuming that these are your values/beliefs, you should do X" without taking a position on whether those values/beliefs are correct: it can be valuable and action-guiding for such people!