It feels like unstructured play makes people better/stronger in a way that structured play doesn't.
What do I mean? Unstructured play is the sort of stuff I used to do with my best friend in high school:
unscrewing all the cabinet doors in my parents' house, turning them upside down and/or backwards, then screwing them back on
jumping in and/or out of a (relatively slowly) moving car
making a survey and running it on people at the mall
covering pool noodles with glow-in-the-dark paint, then having pool noodle sword fights with them at night while the paint is still wet, so we can tell who's winning by who's glowing more
In contrast, structured play is more like board games or escape rooms or sports. It has fixed rules. (Something like making and running a survey can be structured play or unstructured play or not play at all, depending on the attitude with which one approaches it. Do we treat it as a fun thing whose bounds can be changed at any time?)
I'm not quite sure why it feels like unstructured play makes people better/stronger, and I'd be curious to hear other peoples' thoughts on the question. I'm going to write some of mine below, but maybe don't look at them yet if you want to answer the question yourself?
Just streaming thoughts a bit...
Unstructured play encourages people to question the frame, change the environment/rules, treat social constraints as malleable. It helps one to notice degrees of freedom which are usually taken to be fixed.
Because there's so much more freedom, unstructured play pushes people to notice their small desires moment-to-moment and act on them, rather than suppress them (as is normal most of the time).
Unstructured play offers an environment in which to try stuff one wouldn't normally try, in a way which feels lower-risk.
... and probably others. But I'm not sure which such factor(s) most account for my gut feeling that unstructured play makes people better/stronger. (Or, to account for the other possibility, maybe the causal arrow goes the other way, i.e. better/stronger people engage more in unstructured play, and my gut feeling is picking up on that.) Which factor is most important for growing better/stronger?
I'm not quite sure why it feels like unstructured play makes people better/stronger
(Written before reading the second part of the OP.)
I don't really share that feeling[1]. But if I conditioned on that being true and then produced an answer:
Obviously because it trains research taste.
Or, well, the skills in that cluster. If you're free to invent/modify the rules of the game at any point, then if you're to have fun, you need to be good at figuring out what rules would improve the experience for you/everyone, and what ideas would detract from it. You're simult... (read more)