LESSWRONG
LW

World Modeling
Frontpage

5

[ Question ]

Why do we enjoy music?

by metachirality
14th May 2024
1 min read
A
1
3

5

World Modeling
Frontpage

5

Why do we enjoy music?
15Anna Gajdova
1metachirality
2Viliam
New Answer
New Comment

1 Answers sorted by
top scoring

Anna Gajdova

May 14, 2024

158

You might enjoy Kevin Simler's review of Why Do People Sing?: Music in Human Evolution. It's a beautifully written essay offering some speculative and surprising answers I don't want to spoil. 

Re: predictive error explanation: You might say that a good music piece needs the right balance of familiarity, emotional impact and surprise even when you are listening to it on repeat. 

Add Comment
[-]metachirality1y10

I don't think I'm really looking for something like that, since it doesn't touch on the perception of music as much as it does the reasons why we have it.

Reply
1 comment, sorted by
top scoring
Click to highlight new comments since: Today at 2:56 AM
[-]Viliam1y20

why specifically sounds arranged in patterns through time over anything else?

We already have speech, so the progression could be something like: saying the same things (repeating what the high-status person or the the person you love said)... saying the same things together (in a religious ritual)... singing together... listening to the music (and imagining that you are singing along?)

Reply
Moderation Log
More from metachirality
View more
Curated and popular this week
A
1
1

Enjoying music doesn't seem to have any obvious purpose. Sure you can argue it strengthens social bonds, but why specifically sounds arranged in patterns through time over anything else?

At least with humor you can say it's about identifying the generating function of some observation which is sort of like reducing prediction error in predictive coding (and I suspect something like this is the basis for aesthetics) but I can't fit music into being anything like this.