This is a special post for quick takes by anaguma. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
Just trying to model the possible aftermath of this.
Even if no plagiarism occurred, if training on chats contributed meaningfully to OAI's result, there's still a strong disincentive for any R&D firm against using OAI products. Plus, OAI's behavior (if true) is extremely off-putting. The general culture around knowledge production would shift toward hoarding knowledge, which I think would be a huge loss to progress. I also suspect that many people put all AI companies into the same mental bucket, to where the actions of one heavily influence how they feel about the others. So, even if OAI is the one who screwed up, I think people would broadly distrust any AI at all.
I think this case has much greater potential for igniting anti-AI sentiment than previous complaints about artistic plagiarism. The analogous case for AI art is a human studying an artist and being inspired. We already see that as inspiration, not plagiarism, so the average person doesn't immediately see AI art as plagiarism unless there's an extreme similarity. But in this case, the closest analogy is an academic finding someone's unpublished work, using that to produce their own, and then rushing to publish to seize more of the credit. Even if OAI never saw the previous work, I could see this type of narrative being pushed among the general public. OAI's behavior is weird enough to weaken credibility, so it seems likely that some people will dismiss any plausible explanation in favor of a conspiracy narrative. The HF incident is perfect timing for OAI to appear as general liars.
I'm immensely curious as to how this plays out. X is already buzzing with accusations of intentional plagiarism. Please let me know if I'm missing anything in my guesses.